Unrenovated single-family house from 1973 - Renovation or new construction?

  • Erstellt am 2020-04-05 19:32:44

nordanney

2020-04-07 10:51:25
  • #1
The client should take a look at the individual measures proposed by the architect and question them. Do I really need to completely renew the roof of a house from ’73, or is insulating the top floor ceiling enough = savings potential €45k ==> just to possibly have the attic/storage room insulated? The architect probably just calculated everything generously, whether necessary or not. I maintain that €270k in costs for the renovation of the single-family house is clearly too much.
 

t4ker727

2020-04-07 15:10:24
  • #2


Year of construction ~1960. Consequently, only slightly older. It is even only 1.5 stories and not a full 2 stories like the OP's.

Ceiling basement / ground floor: hollow core planks between double T beams
Ceiling ground floor / upper floor: wooden beam ceilings
 

Winniefred

2020-04-07 17:30:51
  • #3
Something to always consider is the ecological advantage of renovating. I see only advantages for renovating here: the floor plan fits, the structure is good, you know the house. Significantly reduced costs for the outdoor facilities. It doesn't get better than that. If almost everything is actually from 1973, I would do a major overhaul and do a full renovation. So everything new inside and outside, only leaving the walls that are still needed. If the heating is not too old, you can continue to use it (what kind is it?). Have the house connections checked and renewed if necessary. Otherwise, with that year of construction, I wouldn’t leave anything and would rather do everything now instead of being annoyed about crumbling plaster in 10 years. There are things you don't do anymore once you live inside. I don’t know your house. But 270,000€ also seems too much to me if you don’t have particularly extravagant taste. On the other hand, you will always find a way to spend your money if you want to. I’m thinking more like 150,000-200,000€ if you don’t have to save. But as I said, better to plan more and be happy later if there is some left over. Since no one here knows your wishes and the house, but the architect does, who knows, maybe you do need more after all. The value of a house is often determined primarily by the location. More than by the age. A fancy new building for 400,000€ will bring little money in resale if it is in the middle of nowhere, and a wreck is still solid investment ("Betongold") in Munich.
 

11ant

2020-04-07 17:39:37
  • #4

That is already almost rare.

Above all, the elimination of the waiting time for the outdoor facilities would be a significant comfort aspect for me. Garden instead of training ground
 

Pinky0301

2020-04-07 18:21:23
  • #5

I can only agree. Our new house is still being renovated, but we have been able to use the garden including the pool since last summer
It's best to check with KfW and Bafa about funding opportunities. That can add up to several tens of thousands of Euros
 

Winniefred

2020-04-07 18:24:49
  • #6
Right, definitely take advantage of funding. We have already celebrated some first birthdays in the matured garden during the renovation, wonderful!
 

Similar topics
16.02.2011Renovating the house - What do you advise me?21
27.04.2020Cat-proof garden16
02.09.2015How large should a garden be at minimum?11
29.02.2016Outdoor facilities in self-performance12
12.04.2016Heat pump: better inside the house or in the garden?38
08.11.2017Looking for a suitable tree for the garden11
10.05.2018Setting up a garden of approximately 600 sqm - rough cost estimate?33
02.04.2018How to secure a slope and design a garden entrance cost-effectively?27
28.03.2018Separate water meter for garden to save on wastewater charges?24
27.04.2018City villa 190m² with driveway & garden on the south side30
13.09.2018Garden landscaping disaster or does it really have to be this expensive?30
02.10.2018Garden landscaper offer ok or rather totally exaggerated?103
05.09.2022Need your assessment for the renovation of a rental property37
28.07.2020Renovating a half-timbered house - low ceiling heights, are there possibilities?36
13.01.2021Cost estimation for demolition and new construction75
28.03.2021Flat rate cost for house renovation - what is realistic?15
14.08.2021Build, buy, renovate? - How reasonable is it when desiring a modern house?18
04.08.2022Buy an existing single-family house with a large plot and renovate it22
24.08.2022Renovate or demolish and rebuild?12
10.04.2023Renovate an old building or build new? Experiences?35

Oben