House Purchase - Complicated Situation

  • Erstellt am 2021-03-17 09:15:36

Tassimat

2021-03-19 20:11:16
  • #1
No no, the calculation is wrong, because the mother is being "cheated" out of a lot of money. I see the calculation like this: The house is worth €600,000. From that, €240,000 in debts are deducted. Mother and father thus each receive €180,000. If the father needs €80,000 of the €180,000 himself, one could at most still talk about an inheritance share of €100,000.
 

Hausbautraum20

2021-03-19 20:11:31
  • #2


Unfortunately, I don’t understand that at all.

600k - 200k = 400k
For that, your mother would also have to gift you 100k, otherwise the calculation does not work like that.
Does she do that?

Then it gets even stranger:
400k - 240k = 160k.

So your father and mother have assets of 160k.
How on earth are 2 siblings supposed to be paid/inherited 200k each with that??

So everything else of your/your thoughts I find understandable, but the calculation just doesn’t add up.
 

Hausbautraum20

2021-03-19 20:25:22
  • #3
Maybe you could write more about yourselves? Maybe you can manage 600k plus renovation after all? Or the renovation might be smaller at first? In case of inheritance, your debt burden will decrease later anyway.

Or maybe an interest-free loan from your father between 100k and 200k. That way you have less interest and installment to pay, maybe get better bank interest rates, your dad knows his house is in good hands... If your dad needs the money, he gets it back, and if not, you keep it as an advance inheritance forever. The siblings won’t be significantly disadvantaged by the few saved interests. In case of inheritance, they don’t suffer any loss. We have smaller interest-free loans from both parents with maturity in 15 years. In 15 years, we will either have inherited or take out the next loan agreement. If someone unexpectedly needs the money back, we have to increase our bank loan. That would be uncomfortable for us, but still feasible. So we are happy with this solution :)
 

pagoni2020

2021-03-19 21:00:01
  • #4
Above all, I would have preferred a less snappy response, but well...... Reliable: notarized security from the parents – only then an advance payment to the children who provide care. Is that so difficult? You know what I mean....for sure. It’s called careeeee! Thanks for the diagnosis, I’ll just take two of those sedative drops for old people right away. It’s called lived experience in many cases, and here might already be the next case. The brother has already left a scent mark that startled you, but he wants nothing other than you, only the best! You dangerously downplay the house value and parental claims (your brother emphasizes them), "Mom is happy about a quick 80,000 anyway," "Dad only wants the motorhome," "the siblings don’t want the house anyway"....oops....then let’s just take it....what a coincidence. That’s exactly how I read it. It’s okay if a child wants the house, but as a “senior,” I want to be secured until my death through MY money, and without this SECURITY (independent of the heirs’ moods), I wouldn’t recommend anyone to take such a risk. People change......and growing old in uncertainty is torture. Fortunately, I don’t care about your thing, but I probably come from a different generation than you and therefore wonder about such flippant arrogance as I read above. Maybe it was emotional, then be happy at least someone is thinking for your parents too. I don’t expect you to hold my sippy cup sometime, but maybe you should think more about who will do it then with Mom & Dad or where it will be paid from when you yourself currently have no time or desire. Accepting criticism or recognizing it as a possible gain because maybe one hasn’t thought enough about some things is not everyone’s thing.
 

ypg

2021-03-19 22:08:09
  • #5
It's working... worked hard for a house for decades, which is supposed to be for the children, so within the family! One child takes it, all in all, 80,000€ remain from the whole life - for old age :P
 

Joedreck

2021-03-20 06:37:26
  • #6

You obviously did not fully read my post. If not possible, distance yourself. That brings peace to all parties involved. You do your stuff without looking at others or considering others.
 

Similar topics
03.05.2011KfW loan okay or is there a cheaper option?10
30.04.2013Loan with an interest rate of 2.51% - Tips for financing22
18.04.2015Is a building savings contract still worthwhile with the current interest rates?10
03.01.2016surprising bill, no cost estimate12
20.06.2016Error in financing?280
27.03.2017Forward loan - Secure interest rates now?53
18.11.2016Electrician's invoice after 2.5 years - What are my rights?18
17.10.2011Need an invoice for an IKEA BESTÅ BURS TV bench21
17.09.2018No special repayments possible with loans. How to save money?15
16.11.2018Combination of building savings bank, KFW and loan10
21.06.2019Larger loan with only 5 years interest fixation14
31.07.2019Is a bullet loan and ETF currently worth considering?27
29.07.2019Bullet loans & annuity loans combined - sensible?28
04.09.2019Avoid commitment interest - 100% loan payout13
14.05.2020Financing Land & House - 2 Different Loans34
11.01.2021Financing offer: TA loan with building savings contract24
14.02.202210 or 17 years fixed interest rate on a 250k loan?24
04.02.2022Follow-up financing for two loans with different terms14
29.09.2022High interest rates with fixed interest, alternative flex loans?54

Oben