Floor plan: A life in the dream or nightmare house?

  • Erstellt am 2021-12-06 21:20:55

Hobbyplaner

2021-12-06 21:20:55
  • #1
Hello dear building community!
We are currently in the planning phase of our single-family house and would like to subject our floor plan to your critical feedback. Thank you already for your time!
Everything that is not yet filled in is not fixed to date. Here is the information about the plot and the plan:

Development plan/restrictions
Plot size approx. 730 m²
Slope No
Floor area ratio 0.49
Edge development No
Number of parking spaces 4
Roof shape Gable roof
Terrace orientation facing south

Requirements of the builders - <Description (priority)>

Garage:

    [*]Garage with space for bikes, lawnmower, etc. (1)
    [*]Passage to the house, possibly with a small cloakroom. (1)
    [*]Additionally a small separate workshop. (2)
    [*]Access from the workshop to the outside. (3)

Laundry room:

    [*]Should be near the kitchen -> ground floor (2)

Kitchen, living, dining:

    [*]Semi-open (possibly visual room separation) (2)
    [*]Cooking island (1)
    [*]Kitchen near the terrace (1)
    [*]Kitchen in the west. Ideally morning sun. (1)
    [*]Glass front facing southwest, privacy screen to the east or L-shape. (1)
    [*]Bench in front of a large window near dining table/kitchen (1)
    [*]Covered terrace (1)

Entrance ground floor:

    [*]Staircase in the entrance area (1)
    [*]Entrance can also be designed open to the kitchen or living room (2)

Parents’ bathroom:

    [*]Toilet separated within the bathroom (3)
    [*]Not too large (3)
    [*]Directly accessible (via dressing room) from bedroom (1)

Bedroom

    [*]Room/distance between bedroom and children’s room (3)
    [*]Dressing room to the bathroom (1)

Children’s rooms

    [*]As large as possible and as similar as possible. (1)
    [*]Children’s rooms next to each other (2)

General

    [*]Higher room height (at least 260 cm) on the ground floor (2)
    [*]Small light well on the ground floor (3)
    [*]Gable roof,
    [*]Single-family house
    Basement Yes
    [*]Floors 2
    Number of persons 2 adults 2 children (from 1 year)
    [*]Space requirements on the ground floor office (home office), laundry room, living and dining, WC, double garage
    No overnight guests, therefore no guest room (couch in office)
    semi-open architecture (e.g. living room separable with sliding door)
    modern construction
    open kitchen with cooking island

    Number of dining seats 8
    Fireplace Yes
    Balcony Yes
    [*]Other: To the east there is a 3-story apartment building overlooking the plot
    [*](Only) garage may be built closer to plot boundary

House design
Planning comes from a planner of a construction company
What we especially like is the room layout on the upper floor. All bedrooms have a wide view over the meadow.

In the plan, the 3-story neighboring house is drawn in gray on the east side. The terrace is supposed to provide privacy from that, which is quite given by the 2.5 m deep balcony. However, we are not sure whether the kitchen and living room will be too dark, as not much sunlight will reach these rooms. Possibly the problem with privacy/wind protection/light could also be solved with an L-shape (see pencil sketch as example).

Could do without the relatively large parents’ bedroom, the children’s bathroom is also somewhat large.
Could not do without: privacy- and wind-protected terrace, office (home office), passage from garage, laundry on the ground floor, equally sized children’s rooms, two bathrooms, large dining/living area

Why did the design turn out as it is now?

Due to own wishes, input from the planner, and examples from magazines.

What makes it particularly good or bad in your eyes?
The rooms are located on the floors and in the directions as desired. To the west of the kitchen there is a row of cupboards, of which we are not really sure yet how to use this corner (any tips very welcome). It is probably a bit too far from the kitchen to install oven, etc. there.

What is the most important/basic question about the floor plan summarized in 130 characters?

We would like feedback on the entire floor plan. We are especially interested in:

    [*]Variant 1 or Variant 2 (pencil sketch)





 

Myrna_Loy

2021-12-06 21:54:43
  • #2
Well, all the must-haves of 2021 are included there. But what I don’t understand – there is a parents' bathroom but no children's bathroom? And I don’t see any spatial separation from the children's rooms either?
 

pagoni2020

2021-12-06 22:10:01
  • #3
At first glance, it looks clear and tidy, which could also be related to the presentation style that I find pleasant. On the ground floor, I don’t like that the WC is practically in the middle of the living area; I would rather place it in the entrance area. The hallway itself is generously sized at almost 19 sqm but in my opinion difficult to furnish. Additionally, the often preferred access to the garage is something I would definitely omit, also because it takes up a lot of space. I don’t particularly like the straight staircase, especially in this position. The two doors to the bedroom and bathroom almost clash with each other, which feels unpleasant. You go through the first door and are practically standing like in an airlock to the bathroom. We recently had a similar setup with the bed in front of a half-height wall. However, in that case the access to the bathroom was framed by your currently planned wardrobe wall of 1m width, practically surrounded by wardrobes. Otherwise, the plan still needs correct measurements for the table, sofa, passages, fireplace, etc., as that is often where the problem lies.
 

haydee

2021-12-06 22:31:19
  • #4
What budget are we talking about?
Why food and laundry on the ground floor when there is a basement?
Should the roofs be built as drawn?
 

ypg

2021-12-06 22:49:06
  • #5
But there is a children's bathroom and spatial separation after all. Take another look? I'm wondering what lies to the west in the three-story building, that the whole terrace is blocked off like this and there's fear of side windows. Do you walk around naked all day that you're afraid of curious looks because of this? I wonder if the tenants feel the same? "Oh dear, now someone wants to build there - they'll be constantly peeking into our windows" :cool: About the design: the shared balcony for children and parents with panoramic windows really holds more interesting stories for the breakfast table ;) The flat roof or extension/garage has a massive presence that does not harmonize with the two-story building body. The house seems to be tipping, the entrance front disguises itself with an industrial hall look. The 3D does not match the drawings?! The roof lies on the upper floor and seems to crush it. This may be because of the too large overhang, but also due to the rather low roof pitch. Personally, I find the windows a bit boring. Almost only windows on the south side, none on the east and west. They do nothing for the comfort in sleeping rooms: it becomes disproportionately hot in the summer months, and cross-ventilation is impossible. However, it gives a good cave-like character. The open space is estimated to be 5 meters wide. I consider that too narrow for the kitchen layout: there is actually only space for a corner bench. If there is a wish for a freestanding table, then the room is tight. Tall cabinets are too far away and the traffic routes cross and interfere. Is the storage room also a pantry? Then the fireplace is in the wrong place. The bathroom upstairs is too small for a T. The door can go. Nevertheless, I like the upper floor because it is clearly divided. A bit more play with the windows and it's good... Maybe also two balcony dividers like in a hotel ;) ... was a joke :D With the courtyard driveway, roof overhang, and generous terrace, there is more than enough sealed area, right? Overall, I miss balance.
 

11ant

2021-12-07 01:11:09
  • #6
I can't quite decide what I should find more terrifying: 1) the building "concept" with the extreme displacement of the two floors with a chalet half on a flat-roof bungalow and half in the air above, or 2) my déjà vu with an almost unrecognizably idiosyncratic interpretation of a Bien-Zenker M165 Wuppertal by
 

Similar topics
17.12.2013Floor plan single-family house with double garage and terrace19
18.05.2016Help needed with window arrangement!32
30.07.2014Bungalow with 140 sqm and garage in the floor plan13
21.04.2015Is a floor plan with a garage feasible on the property?29
14.08.2016Our targeted floor plan - please provide assessments67
07.07.2016Floor plan of our bungalow82
09.02.2018Floor plan for a 150 sqm single-family house with a living room facing north21
26.03.2018Floor plan of a gable roof house 172 sqm - Please share your opinions23
19.02.2019House orientation for new construction on a north-facing plot - ideas, tips?27
08.07.2019Bungalow 135 sqm: Floor plan + windows104
07.09.2021Floor plan design experiences - criticism?166
12.07.2020Single-family house floor plan 170 sqm for 4 persons with garage20
16.01.2021Floor plan of a new gable roof house, 145 sqm, 9 x 11.5 m, shortly before building application32
08.03.2021Bungalow Floor Plan Opinions31
29.11.2021Window sill height 130 in the bedroom / study?93
25.11.2022Floor plan: Open living room including fireplace - Feedback11
24.01.2023Floor plan of a single-family house without a basement, 3 children's rooms, and an office18
23.02.2023Floor plan single-family house, 200m2, 2 full floors, garage, without basement39
12.02.2024Are non-floor-to-ceiling windows in the living room outdated? What curtains?17
27.12.2024Floor plan of a single-family house 155m², without basement, 3 children's rooms, 1 office38

Oben