Suitable heating system for new construction - how to choose?

  • Erstellt am 2021-07-26 12:07:30

hampshire

2021-08-05 13:25:50
  • #1

We currently only open once (in the morning and close again in the evening (most)).
 

rdwlnts

2021-08-05 14:55:22
  • #2

The timeline is of course different. However, the timeline of a centuries-old tree is also different from the timeline of a fireplace fire.
The climate neutrality of a tree that is burned purely for aesthetics is and remains a myth.
In terms of calorific value, wood—especially wood that is too wet—is worse than coal. Taking all effects together (there are many more), the advantage of wood over coal shrinks immensely.
 

RotorMotor

2021-08-05 14:59:10
  • #3
So just burn coal in the fireplace? :cool: I'm not sure if it looks that nice and really benefits the environment.
 

hampshire

2021-08-05 16:00:38
  • #4
I'll pretend as if you really don't understand this and give the hint to calculate in geological epochs. The age of a tree is irrelevant. A few million years, on the other hand, are very relevant. Coal is a long-term storage of CO2 from a climatically completely different era. What you add from coal, you cannot really compensate, whereas what you add from wood you can compensate by letting biomass regrow simultaneously. You cannot compensate the CO2 from fossil fuels with plant growth. That is the meaning of the timeline. Burning wood is not climate neutral. If you consider a small cycle and you produce the biomass per year that you remove and burn, the climate damage remains within narrow limits (provided this biomass would not have grown anyway) – of course, it would be better for the climate to simply avoid energy consumption (whether wood or otherwise) just for fun. But I definitely won’t become a fundamentalist about that. Coal has great energetic properties – no question. But the mere fact that we are breaking down ancient CO2 storages and pumping it massively into the atmosphere disqualifies coal as an acceptable energy source – it doesn’t matter at all whether the energy density is better than that of wood – wet or dry. You happily mix levels here and thus hit the zeitgeist. There is no longer a good argument for coal if you focus on climate-friendly energy. Quite simply. For wood, it is different – although wood consumption also has problematic effects.
 

rdwlnts

2021-08-05 16:27:28
  • #5
I gladly return the mixing of the relevant durations to you. Also, that your opinion corresponds to popular belief but has detached itself from the scientific consensus.
 

sub-xero

2021-08-27 07:25:36
  • #6
Air-to-water heat pumps are (especially compared to groundwater or brine heat pumps) cost-effective, completely sufficient for a single-family home (hot water and heating), and straightforward to install. I also initially considered groundwater or brine heat pumps because of their efficiency. However, in the end, they are so expensive that it never pays off.
 

Similar topics
03.06.2016Trench collector brine-water heat pump or air-water heat pump?49
06.10.2015Groundwater as a geothermal energy source13
19.05.2021Experiences with brine heat pump491
06.12.2015Heat pump / final energy demand / annual performance factor20
21.06.2016Heat pump with photovoltaics vs gas and solar thermal52
23.09.2017Ring trench collector for brine heat pumps18
26.10.2020Groundwater heat pump - disadvantages?19
31.05.2018Air-water heat pump including ventilation system vs. brine heat pump including ventilation system15
01.02.2019Controlled residential ventilation with cooling: brine geothermal heat pump instead of air-to-water heat pump?30
25.03.2019Heating concept for single-family house new build approx. 190m²: Split heat pump vs. ground source (brine)13
22.11.2019Feedback on heat pump / offer requested!46
11.12.2019Gas heating or heat pump air (Mitsubishi?) or groundwater16
11.06.2020Active cooling function heat pump or air conditioner in new construction12
08.07.2020LWZ 8 CS Premium combi made of air-water heat pump, controlled residential ventilation and hot water storage tank15
19.04.2021Comparison of groundwater / brine / air heat pump27
23.06.2021Brine water / Air water - Specifications for the construction area10
07.12.2021Is a brine-water heat pump still worthwhile with KfW 40+?34
28.06.2023Sole-water heat pump with ground probe experiences?42
31.03.2024Which brine-water heat pump Viessmann, Niebe or Stiebel WPE-I 10 H12
11.02.2025KFW 40, Ground-water heat pump worthwhile or is air-water better?15

Oben