Is the floor plan suitable for a multi-generation house?

  • Erstellt am 2025-05-19 18:47:42

Dutchi695

2025-05-20 00:19:57
  • #1


The basement is primarily intended to be used as a utility basement, that is, storage and hobby room or party cellar. It is certainly planned to build a small garden shed for the lawnmower and such. The idea for the bicycles was to additionally store them in the double garage (if long enough).

Unfortunately, the land costs are extremely high for us. We applied for two plots in the building area and unfortunately got the smaller one (the larger was over 500sqm). But with land prices of up to €1000 / sqm, you have to make compromises or move far into the hinterland and simply accept a commuting distance of 45 minutes or more. Living "unfortunately" in a holiday region, land is very expensive and very hard to get.
 

Dutchi695

2025-05-20 00:32:14
  • #2


Thank you very much for the detailed answer.

I have partly already written the background in previous answers. Currently, the parents-in-law (both just under 60) live on the third floor in 120sqm. In the future, they no longer want to carry the heavy groceries so far up and would therefore prefer to live on the ground floor. Initially, it was planned that both parties would have direct garden access, but that option was well beyond the budget. They are willing to downsize in terms of living space (but not below 80sqm).

An asymmetrical semi-detached house was also far above our budget, so we decided on the current variant. According to the developer, building upwards is cheaper than building outwards – which also benefits the small plot ;-)

My wife would like the "character" of a house and therefore does not want everything on one level. That was the reason we chose upper floor + attic.

I have already noted your tip about scale-accurate furniture and we will definitely follow up on it.
I am happy to answer any further questions.
 

kbt09

2025-05-20 00:53:11
  • #3
The plan in is a first orientation, but otherwise not sufficient. There are not even any measurements included. Where will the garage be? And is it allowed to extend beyond the building boundary?
 

11ant

2025-05-20 01:00:37
  • #4


Hiring an independent architect is usually roughly cost-neutral, because it is a misconception to "calculate" the fee as a useless cost increase. You can only "optimize" something that is at least reasonably good. A granny flat, even if only "pre-equipped," immediately incurs construction costs and parking space requirements, even if it does not pay for itself. Would the development plan even allow a third residential unit and/or holiday apartment?
If fulfilling the demand is already difficult, this applies all the more to exceeding the demand. Even a beginner in the very first semester should logically be able to deduce the opposite of the general contractor’s April Fools’ proposal from this.
Show the elevations of the property.
 

hanse987

2025-05-20 06:52:07
  • #5

However, these are only two official parking spaces because generally a parking space must be usable independently of the other. How many parking spaces are required per residential unit in the development plan?

Regarding the intended EWL: How many residential units does your development plan allow for your property?
 

ypg

2025-05-20 09:00:59
  • #6

You should definitely draw everything yourself.
It's no shame to have a small plot. However, you have to look for space for everything yourself. For example, there would be trapped parking spaces, which are not practical for two families and probably not approved either.
The development plan plays a big role.
Also, bicycles etc. cannot be pushed along a house wall or past cars in tight spaces.
You also need your building window for a better overview. And then the plot width. Draw everything to scale on graph paper.
The rooms themselves work and none of them are too small.
 

Similar topics
15.08.2018Basic floor area ratio / floor area ratio for plots without a development plan: How to calculate? Experiences?18
18.04.2019Development plan of 1998 - Setting the eaves height to a maximum of 3.00m12
25.07.2019Bungalow with special development plan ... more ideas?41
30.07.2019Non-compliance with the development plan by the neighbor101
09.04.2020Existing buildings on plots in a new development plan27
02.02.2020Error from the office - No legally compliant and error-free development plan67
06.05.2020Is the community required to develop if a development plan exists?20
22.08.2020Development in the second row without a development plan? What can we do?22
24.01.2021Plot - Ideas and suggestions on orientation and development plan33
05.07.2021Additional costs for residential units98
27.01.2025Interpretation of the 1957 development plan <-> possibilities for new construction36
06.09.2021Forest land plot assessment land use plan / development plan17
12.01.2022Union of two plots - redefine the building envelope?20
05.12.2022Development plan unclear regarding the number of floors and height on the slope55
05.09.2023Application for a new development area: Selection of plots41
30.06.2023Heating for bungalow with 2 residential units11
14.04.2025Floor plan of a new multi-family house with 3 residential units, living area approx. 350 m²72
10.03.2025Building despite residential units/multi-family house stipulated in the development plan20
25.07.2025How many residential units are possible?19
18.07.2025Passive house requirements of the city are not included in the development plan24

Oben