Is an offer binding or are deviations allowed?

  • Erstellt am 2018-07-05 20:03:57

Knallkörper

2018-08-12 16:04:24
  • #1
Probably the planning is lacking. If no detailed execution planning is available for such details as Snowy described, it is also "too late" for the supervisor.
 

Snowy36

2018-08-12 16:09:17
  • #2
There was a plan, but the carpenter messed it up ... who will find a solution for it now is questionable, and since I am the client and have the problem, I tried to solve it ... Monday we’ll clarify with the supervisor what we are going to do ...
 

MayrCh

2018-08-12 17:43:51
  • #3

A defect mainly exists in individual contracting when the ordered scope deviates. However, given the history of this thread, it becomes difficult to prove the contractually owed scope of the carpenter’s trade. Was the vapor barrier foil even specified/commissioned/part of the contract?
 

Bookstar

2018-08-12 18:30:43
  • #4
That is unfortunately incorrect. As a layperson, you do not have to commission technical requirements separately. The craftsman must work properly and according to aRdT, no matter what is stated in the offer. It is simply the law!
 

MayrCh

2018-08-12 18:51:08
  • #5
Well, if I commission a roof without, for example, a vapor barrier, because the vapor barrier is installed by myself or by another trade, that does not necessarily mean that a deviation from the state of the art here constitutes a defect. Delivered as ordered.
 

Snowy36

2018-08-12 18:57:29
  • #6
Then it would have to be in writing somewhere that you want to deviate from it on purpose ....

For our balcony doors without a threshold, for example, it explicitly states that they are not rainproof like this and we are explicitly informed that they are doing this expressly at our request and are thus off the hook if we should complain one day that the parquet gets wet ...

But there is the lawyer to clarify that
 

Similar topics
10.05.2015Screed uneven - defect removal refused52
26.03.2016Garage base draws water - defect?28
07.04.2016Defect?? Glued engineered parquet doesn’t stick everywhere?!11
02.10.2016Vapor barrier vs vapor retarder21
12.09.2017Roof constructed too flat - Construction company does not acknowledge the defect12
06.11.2017Facade defect: mortar residues and smears - defect or not?18
20.05.2018Dense, well-insulated wooden house without plastic? (Vapor barrier)21
21.09.2018Has adhesive been pushed out between the window panes - defect?27
31.10.2018Concern about vapor barrier - air from ceiling outlet12
24.01.2020Drainage in front of garage door is missing / correct it? Defect?15
27.02.2020Is the vapor barrier in the roof vapor-permeable? Yes? No!16
16.08.2020Bathtub misaligned - defect?15
29.12.2020Drywall and vapor barrier done differently24
29.01.2021Should the awning maker make corrections here? - Is this a defect?11
06.05.2021Brickwork sealing not compliant with standards, minor defect10
16.05.2021Handle position on the window not centered - defect?51

Oben