We do not have a hip roof but a gable roof over our bungalow, but we have also given a lot, a lot of thought to our roof pitch and created many sketches. The first reason was the appearance. The best feeling was at 25 degrees. In the later planning, we even went up to 26 degrees. That gave us a few centimeters under the ridge in the attic. We still find it perfect today!
My impression: I find the roof on the pink house too flat for a two-story city house. Somehow the proportions are not right. I like the roof on the brown city house better. Best regards, Steffi.