Construction description by architects: Who has experience?

  • Erstellt am 2017-10-27 10:14:46

11ant

2017-10-27 16:09:26
  • #1
Tender and construction service description are two different things. And if they can manage the construction service description in table form with the same quality as the classic text version, then they can hold well-attended seminars on it for their colleagues.
 

ruppsn

2017-10-27 17:31:03
  • #2
Honestly, I don’t see the added value of a construction service specification when building with an architect and individual contracting. You have conversations during the basic evaluation, align expectations, get shown the architect’s "standard" for specific equipment and the cost estimate, and that’s it. What added value does a construction service specification offer if you are not building turnkey or at a fixed price? I only see unnecessary work in the form of a highly precise construction service specification that becomes obsolete at the latest during the first workshop planning meeting. Since you pay for this unnecessary work, I prefer to forgo it and instead talk twice as much with the architect rather than invest time and energy in the construction service specification.

This might be different with the architect and building with a general contractor (GU), but with individual contracting? What is the point? Many positions shift so much in price due to the tenders that either cheaper or more expensive options can be used. In addition, things are added or dropped during the planning process. What good is it to have a construction service specification at the start that lists plastic windows, but due to client wishes, large window areas require wood for structural reasons? Or if the appropriate air-to-water heat pump (LWWP) is selected after the energy/heating load calculation, but another one was initially listed in the construction service specification, and so on and so forth…

With a general contractor or turnkey contract (BT), yes, mandatory and as precise as possible because of the fixed price. With an architect and individual contracting, the construction service specification is outdated the moment it is written and therefore unnecessary. That’s how I handle it...
 

11ant

2017-10-27 18:37:48
  • #3
I can at least understand your argumentation objectively, whereas the statements give me the impression of coming from lazy bums who want to cherry-pick the best parts of their job description and dismiss the more trivial parts; or pursue their profession with a diva attitude like yet unknown star chefs. That really gets on my nerves.
 

Alex85

2017-10-27 18:42:10
  • #4
As said, a construction performance description is of no use to us. Tendering is only due later and takes place of course. Apparently, only the bank wants a construction description.
 

ruppsn

2017-10-27 18:45:20
  • #5

Oh yes, those specimens certainly exist, but we have largely avoided them. I understand the boiling blood in that context very well [emoji4]
 

11ant

2017-10-27 18:53:49
  • #6
... which I can understand: in case of realization, they prefer that, a construction service description simply sounds nicer than the tender documents.
 

Similar topics
18.07.2012What should be considered in a construction service description?10
19.03.2014Comparison of construction performance description! What should we prefer?47
11.11.2014The Old Suffering - Turnkey/Individual Contract38
01.12.2016Construction company rejects change requests in construction service description and construction contract39
13.03.2017Construction planning, construction work description, cost breakdown19
01.12.2017The bank may want a construction service description despite individual subcontract awarding26
31.03.2018Prices have been lumped after modification ideas of the construction service description10
01.08.2018Description of construction services - Performance assessment?12
29.10.2018Earthworks in the construction performance description17
12.04.2019Is the construction performance description detailed enough?14
14.11.2019Have you understood your construction service description?49
23.01.2020Construction work description - Thin slab foundation disadvantageous?11
17.04.2020Construction Performance Description Formulation13
05.11.2023Turnkey vs. Individual Contracting35
11.06.2021Construction performance description from the favorite - Is something missing?65
15.11.2021Wishlist for the architect32
24.04.2022Comparison of construction work description regarding the base slab17
25.06.2022Is the cost estimation by the architect realistic?39
10.08.2022Foundation cushioning Town & Country house construction service description10

Oben