Papierturm
2025-08-15 21:53:48
- #1
When I read this, I thought only one word: "Help!"The standard land value in this area is about 270 Eur. That results in a value of over 200k. Plus demolition costs another approx. 25k. We don’t have that much money for a plot of land where a house is still to be built. He has now suggested to somehow inherit it. But I see big problems here, like inheritance tax. Nephew to uncle is only 20,000 Eur.
Fortunately, the idea seems to be more or less off the table.
If not, let me quickly summarize what would happen if this crazy idea from the uncle were to be carried through:
Without clear legal guardrails around it (where you always have to involve lawyers), the uncle’s idea would appreciate the land twice: 1. Demolition—house would be gone (currently devaluing). 2. New house would be on it (massively increasing value).
The house belongs to the landowner. Not to the one building the house. (Yes, this can be dealt with using certain arrangements, long-term leasehold and such, but here lawyers are urgently needed.)
Meaning: inheritance tax would have to be paid not only for the land but also for the house.
I’ll just leave it at that.
One transfers the land to a "Georg and Uncle land management GbR", gifts Georg a very large share of the shares (gift tax applies). Uncle can still co-decide on use or possible sale. Inheritance tax can largely be avoided this way (the gifted shares in the GbR just have to be high enough).He really wants to keep the land because he doesn’t want any strangers living next to him.
My grandmother and mother are also pushing to take the land because it is so cheap and great. Do you have experience with "family internal" sales/ transfers of real estate?
Risk: Georg and wife become unhappy at the location. Uncle is also not thrilled about the new house next door.
Because you don’t have to.I just can’t understand why people want to deal so little with their finances and taxes.
Funny enough, in my in-law family I once had to untangle a totally confusing inheritance situation because nobody had ever really dealt with it beforehand. Estimated losses due to neglect before the inheritance were over €50,000. But hey, paperwork is annoying, right?