180 sqm non-replacement house, best adaptation to the plot?

It would actually have to be a staircase layout, as the planner drew it, if you prefer a straight one. And when I imagine how I could place it, a void occurs to me... she has that too. In this respect, the planning is not satisfactory, but the way there is understandable.

Thanks! I need to let the draft sink in first. Stupid of me not to notice the staircase/roof slope issue – however, a straight staircase was not the specification, maybe it will be easier if you put a staircase with a landing at the front right? I'll try to work it through... I had also considered the idea of placing the kitchen by the utility room – that could create a lot of space and shorten the distances...

Thank you! I need to let that idea sink in first. Silly of me not to notice the staircase/roof slope - however, a straight staircase was not the requirement, maybe it will be easier if you place a landing staircase at the front right? I'll try to work it through... I had also considered the idea of placing the kitchen in the utility room - it could create a lot of space, shortens the distances...

You are misunderstanding that. The staircase in your design does work. wanted to rotate the straight staircase, which is not possible.

Before I go into it, I’ll just post my floor plan, where the staircase fails.
how high is the sand-lime brick on the attic?

Can you push the upper floor up to the building boundary?

Why? From what I’ve read, they have 2 cars. In 6 years the teenager will have one too… I always argue for a yard that is big enough… and the north balcony, yes it is adjacent to the sauna :D

maybe it will be easier if you put a landing staircase at the front right?

Landing is very massive…

Here are the floor plans before I delete them You can leave a comment so one can see in which direction your thinking is going. I’m not planning for myself ;)
The idea was to continue the diagonal further, so that it has a relation to the house and isn’t placed arbitrarily. You can see the entrance would be angled towards the cars (wall would have to go), the staircase and load-bearing? wall inside takes up the angled wall. Visually separated the extension as plaster, so that the barn is also visually recognizable.
The shed would be a compromise: a roof, closed with a door at the back or front, the other side just a shelter for bikes, mower, and co.
I completely forgot my open space above the dining table :D My staircase aimed to go straight up into the light, so towards the balcony. … Now I have an idea, a central landing staircase NW.
Is it worth starting with that? Later I have an online wine tasting of 6 wines, maybe I should get creative again afterwards … hehe

@11ant those could indeed be legitimate concerns: It became clear from the discussions that she prefers to leave the "building" to a general contractor... and sees herself less responsible when there are 5-9.

Then send the architect to the Museum of Modern Building Sculptures, such institutions are always looking for expert directors.

Don't these balcony extensions spoil the impression of the barn middle section?

I still like the overall impression of the house, indeed a townhouse.

Personally, I have never seen barns as middle sections in townhouses. This building sculpture strikes me more like a short lighthouse including its pedestal island - and somehow as a tribute to Libeskind and Hadid, the architect should make up her mind.

also works with the diagonal.

[ATTACH alt="Grundstueck44.JPG"]61566[/ATTACH]

I would actually rotate it the other way around, so that the funnel entrance and parking space open towards the street and the window front adjusts more to the daily events SW :)

So, now discouraged again :cool: If you don't like that, it's also okay!



The staircase in the attic should be extended further into the hallway.
The upper floor consists of placeholder rooms. The windows are arranged somewhat carelessly by me.