Special repayments or investing in the market? Alternatives?

  • Erstellt am 2021-10-24 13:17:20

hampshire

2021-11-08 11:47:45
  • #1
It does not have to be available. The alternative is simply missing an opportunity to buy a house when the market is bad. The money is not needed for living.
 

guckuck2

2021-11-08 11:55:25
  • #2
Money that is needed has no place in riskier investment forms. For that, one uses money that can be spared in an emergency.
 

matte

2021-11-08 11:55:42
  • #3


Phew, hard to say. What amounts are we talking about? 100% equity or only 10% equity? I definitely wouldn’t leave everything on the instant access savings account, but I’d also be uneasy investing all the required equity. I would probably assume the worst case, numbers just as an example:

Cost of property 600k, equity 300k. 300k loan.

Now the question is, how much loan could you afford if things go south and the property should still be realized? Maximum the 300k or more? If 330k is possible, you can absorb about 30k in quick loss of value in your portfolio.

Now you make an assumption about how much your portfolio is allowed to drop at most. 20%? 30%? Assuming 30% is still okay for you, those 30% must not exceed the 30k you can cover if necessary. So in this example, from the 300k equity you would invest a maximum of 100k.

These numbers do not reflect my opinion, they only illustrate how I would approach it. However, on the other hand, I find it questionable to inflate your mortgage because you lost money gambling. ;)

It’s simply a difficult topic and I’m glad I don’t have to ask myself this question...



If that’s the alternative, that after several years of searching you miss the chance, of course. But many are often not that consistent... ;)
 

Alibert87

2021-11-08 11:56:01
  • #4


I don't see it as missing an opportunity. Even if my performance at the time of sale is negative (minus 10/20%, for example), I would still buy the property despite that.
 

Alibert87

2021-11-08 12:01:35
  • #5
Currently equity 60% portfolio (approx. 80k) / 40% instant access savings (i.e. immediately available) So relatively manageable
 

mayglow

2021-11-08 16:21:33
  • #6

I think that needs to be clarified with the bank. If you don’t sell a portfolio but instead pledge or borrow against it, then usually only a partial value is credited (I believe ETFs often count around 50%??). I would assume that if you want to use it fully, it should be liquidated at that time. But these are just lay guesses and not advice.

We also have a small portion in ETFs that we mentally noted as "could possibly become equity." But the portion is smaller, and we are not actively searching for a house/property anywhere yet, since our time horizon is still longer (more like 5 years+ range, but it’s all still very vague) (I just already fell in love with the topic/forum). If things look bleak on the stock markets in a worst-case scenario, the current idea would be possibly not to touch the portfolio at all, but we’ll see how realistic that really is.
 

Similar topics
28.03.2011Can we afford to build a house without equity?14
26.08.2012Small single-family house, little equity but good income, is it at all feasible?11
20.06.2013Problems with equity - real estate purchase15
26.10.2013Does owning horses/age influence the chance of getting a loan?10
14.01.2014Different share/equity for construction. How to write it firmly?10
17.06.2014House purchase planned at the beginning of 2015 - No equity41
04.09.2014How to use equity14
11.07.2015480,000 loan too high, experiences?36
18.02.2015How much equity is used when purchasing land?13
21.02.2015Impacts on loan when equity is in property17
18.03.2015Buying property feasible - Loan with building savings as equity?12
22.06.2015Land price = complete equity. Finance yes/no?13
22.07.2015Is it possible to build a house with little equity?16
02.02.2016It doesn't work without equity - experience!109
15.09.2016Financing without equity with security?52
26.07.2016Calculation of equity capital in connection with KfW loan28
23.06.2017What loan amount and how much equity capital should be reported to the bank?57
29.05.2021Enough equity? Will we even get a loan?30
02.01.2021Financing evaluation. Specify total equity to the bank?19
11.06.2022Use of Credit vs. Equity41

Oben