Influence of outbuildings on boundary construction

  • Erstellt am 2023-09-11 17:59:06

11ant

2023-09-12 10:58:44
  • #1
I would seriously doubt that information. That would have been a case for , maybe you could ask for help in the green forum "Dimeto". A construction obligation for the main building but then boundary distance for the outbuildings seems strange to me, and to construct a transfer of distance from the neighbor’s outbuilding, which actually enjoys a boundary privilege, is even more absurd. My suspicion is that a diligent trainee misunderstood something. Follow the source in the second block of my post #10, there you see the misery: it’s about a very special semi-detached house, the neighbor has a normal small one and the OP a tiny one, both have outbuildings in the yard (the typical self-sufficiency setup from the 50s with rabbits from own slaughter and such). He now wants to replace the semi-detached house and is supposed to build an extension there, this was already the case two years ago in the old thread (see said link). Now he is supposed to keep a boundary distance with the extension to the new building on the cellar of the demolished semi-detached house, which I consider objectively nonsense and also a misunderstanding (or misinterpretation of the regulations), hence the reference to the expert. Adding a distance surface transfer on top of that tops the nonsense once again.
 

ypg

2023-09-12 11:47:14
  • #2
I understand, because I can recall the thread. I can imagine that the shed extension is possible, but then the distance rule applies independently. And I also believe that you are better off in this forum or in a similar one, but more professionally competent.
 

11ant

2023-09-12 12:37:39
  • #3
We regularly have the case of one-sided boundary extensions—more often in rural areas than here; both in pairs and sporadically. The obligation to build attached usually continues with new constructions, and I can't recall any case where this would be different in the rear area. Except that in a case like this, factual building windows are regularly formed, whereby the new buildings in the area of the main buildings may be two stories and in the area of the sheds may be one story.
 

Franzbrot

2023-09-12 14:48:19
  • #4


It was said earlier that we have to attach to the existing building at the front.
At the back (at the shed), we were/are not allowed to build on, as (according to information at the time) the shed/stable was considered an outbuilding/no residential room and no residential building was allowed to be attached to it.
 

hanse987

2023-09-12 17:34:01
  • #5
How high is the shed?

Isn't there a 3m limit in height? If it is more than 3m, a larger required distance might possibly apply?
 

11ant

2023-09-12 19:00:51
  • #6
This normally applies (as a rule for detached buildings, i.e. boundary setbacks on all sides) to privileged buildings, but not the height, rather the average wall height on the boundary side. And also to each building itself and not its neighbors. I maintain my advice to escalate the question at the said point to a specialist.
 

Similar topics
12.11.2018Double carport with shed 6x9m on the boundary29
17.05.2016Boundary construction garage and shed max. 9 meters - no more possible?20
06.03.2017Single-family house or semi-detached house?37
03.01.2018Demolition and rebuilding or renovation? Which house?13
23.10.2018New construction after triplet birth. Looking forward to your ideas.50
23.05.2019Cultivation obligation according to §6 Building Regulations LSA19
05.03.2020Carport with massive shed30
04.09.2019Insulation of garden house/shed12
02.09.2020Old building or new building?55
24.06.2021Enlarge the garden terrace directly in a new building?16
30.06.2021Construction financing semi-detached house 130m2 healthy?80
27.01.2025Interpretation of the 1957 development plan <-> possibilities for new construction36
08.09.2021Floor plan feedback: Semi-detached house for a 4-person family, self-designed24
26.02.2022Pay off a semi-detached house or invest in a new building (at the employer)?14
21.12.2022Financing & Realization Semi-Detached House Rhine/Main Assessment?13
09.05.2024Floor plan ideas for a detached single-family house as an extension with 3 children's rooms and an office35
04.04.2024Cost savings for demolition and new construction?22
06.06.2024Is a new building financially feasible for us?15
30.08.2024Renovation or demolition and new construction - decision support from the architect?25
17.01.2025New construction - now or wait? Experiences?71

Oben