derschwax
2020-09-22 10:43:40
- #1
Good morning!
My girlfriend and I have reserved a plot of land, which is being sold privately through a realtor, and we have already had an initial meeting with an architect. A second meeting with another architect will follow tomorrow. In the first meeting, needs and wishes were recorded, and in the end, there was a hefty price. We reluctantly swallowed that for now and then drove home in silence for 30 minutes. We continued to research construction prices and found out that—no matter how you look at it—you can’t build much cheaper without accepting compromises.
Since then, my head has been spinning like a floor plan of the house on the plot could look like. My girlfriend dreams of two full floors and looks at beautiful floor plans on Instagram. That is not sensible at all, because in my opinion, a solution deviating from the "standard" is necessary to fulfill our wishes. So these are daydreams that threaten to burst in the near future. Trouble and quarrels are preprogrammed. I’m trying to get ahead of this by reading and “educating myself.”
I hope for honest assessments, advice, and maybe the occasional link to helpful threads.
Questionnaire about your floor plan
Building plan/restrictions
Size of the plot: ~640 m²
Slope: yes
Floor area ratio: 0.4
Floor space index: 0.7
Edge development: 3 m distance
Number of parking spaces: 2
Number of floors: 1
Roof shape: gable roof (24-30° pitch)
Orientation: ridge parallel to the street
Eaves height on valley side: 3 m
Eaves height on mountain side: 6 m
I’ll attach the building plan including an excerpt later so you can also find the plot, as well as aerial photos.
Client requirements
Living area: 160-180 m²
Basement, floors: Full use of the floor space index, basement with double garage and office on the slope side
2 (4) persons: 32 and 30, 2 children planned
Space requirements on the ground floor: cloakroom, guest WC, open living-dining area, additional room (playroom, office (family use), guest room)
Space requirements on the upper floor: 2 children’s rooms with children’s bathroom, 1 master bedroom with dressing room and private bathroom
Office: on the ground floor for family use, home office in the basement
Overnight guests per year: 4
Conservative or modern construction method: rather conservative construction
Open kitchen, cooking island: yes
Number of dining seats: 6-8
Fireplace: yes
Music/stereo wall: no
Balcony: not necessary—but if it fits the floor plan, not a problem either
Garage, carport: double garage in the basement with parking spaces in front of it
Utility garden, greenhouse: no
House design
So far, we have considered that the basement could be pushed forward so that the terrace could be extended in front of the house as a kind of balcony on this offset. We like to enjoy the evening sun. Otherwise, I hold back on ideas and wait to see what the architect will answer to my questions that have arisen in the planning process tomorrow.
What is the most important/fundamental question about the floor plan summarized in 130 characters?
Do you know floor plan designs with similar restrictions (slope, floor space index 0.7, eaves height 3 or 6m)? Or do you have other useful tips for us? The building plan is from 1978—can you negotiate with the city about the regulations?

My girlfriend and I have reserved a plot of land, which is being sold privately through a realtor, and we have already had an initial meeting with an architect. A second meeting with another architect will follow tomorrow. In the first meeting, needs and wishes were recorded, and in the end, there was a hefty price. We reluctantly swallowed that for now and then drove home in silence for 30 minutes. We continued to research construction prices and found out that—no matter how you look at it—you can’t build much cheaper without accepting compromises.
Since then, my head has been spinning like a floor plan of the house on the plot could look like. My girlfriend dreams of two full floors and looks at beautiful floor plans on Instagram. That is not sensible at all, because in my opinion, a solution deviating from the "standard" is necessary to fulfill our wishes. So these are daydreams that threaten to burst in the near future. Trouble and quarrels are preprogrammed. I’m trying to get ahead of this by reading and “educating myself.”
I hope for honest assessments, advice, and maybe the occasional link to helpful threads.
Questionnaire about your floor plan
Building plan/restrictions
Size of the plot: ~640 m²
Slope: yes
Floor area ratio: 0.4
Floor space index: 0.7
Edge development: 3 m distance
Number of parking spaces: 2
Number of floors: 1
Roof shape: gable roof (24-30° pitch)
Orientation: ridge parallel to the street
Eaves height on valley side: 3 m
Eaves height on mountain side: 6 m
I’ll attach the building plan including an excerpt later so you can also find the plot, as well as aerial photos.
Client requirements
Living area: 160-180 m²
Basement, floors: Full use of the floor space index, basement with double garage and office on the slope side
2 (4) persons: 32 and 30, 2 children planned
Space requirements on the ground floor: cloakroom, guest WC, open living-dining area, additional room (playroom, office (family use), guest room)
Space requirements on the upper floor: 2 children’s rooms with children’s bathroom, 1 master bedroom with dressing room and private bathroom
Office: on the ground floor for family use, home office in the basement
Overnight guests per year: 4
Conservative or modern construction method: rather conservative construction
Open kitchen, cooking island: yes
Number of dining seats: 6-8
Fireplace: yes
Music/stereo wall: no
Balcony: not necessary—but if it fits the floor plan, not a problem either
Garage, carport: double garage in the basement with parking spaces in front of it
Utility garden, greenhouse: no
House design
So far, we have considered that the basement could be pushed forward so that the terrace could be extended in front of the house as a kind of balcony on this offset. We like to enjoy the evening sun. Otherwise, I hold back on ideas and wait to see what the architect will answer to my questions that have arisen in the planning process tomorrow.
What is the most important/fundamental question about the floor plan summarized in 130 characters?
Do you know floor plan designs with similar restrictions (slope, floor space index 0.7, eaves height 3 or 6m)? Or do you have other useful tips for us? The building plan is from 1978—can you negotiate with the city about the regulations?