Civil Engineer vs. Architect

  • Erstellt am 2017-04-15 20:13:30

Lumpi_LE

2017-04-15 22:33:28
  • #1
I also forgot my winking smiley [emoji6]
 

MIA_SAN_MIA__

2017-04-16 21:46:56
  • #2
And what costs (only the approvable plan without construction supervision) for a single-family house are we talking about here in each case?
 

Barossi

2017-04-16 21:56:36
  • #3
Please keep in mind that a good architect can create a beautiful (and sensible) floor plan. This can save a lot of money due to a possibly more sensible layout.

The first conversation with a structural engineer:
Did you bring a floor plan? I can build that...

Especially in phases 1-4, money can really be saved, and this phase should be very well considered....
 

Lumpi_LE

2017-04-16 21:58:00
  • #4
In the case of a detached house, negotiation matters, theoretically depending on the cost of the property and the HOAI, correspond to about €10k for a normal house.
 

11ant

2017-04-16 22:02:10
  • #5


This is told to you by the Fee Structure for Architects and Engineers (HOAI), it depends on the object (more expensive, larger house is more expensive; also whether it is detached or has to be integrated into a building gap makes a difference).

Simply put: more expensive house, more expensive planning.

The most expensive architect is the one you "save"



As far as I know, only the architect owes you the "plan approved for permission."



Yes, the HOAI is a framework, negotiating is allowed.
 

MIA_SAN_MIA__

2017-04-16 22:06:59
  • #6
Is there an approximate guideline value for a typical detached single-family house with about 190 sqm and a basement? I am currently dealing with such basic matters anyway, but I am also interested in what something like this costs in order to be able to create a cost plan at some point.
 

Similar topics
27.05.2011How to plan the process for your own single-family house?22
26.08.2012Small single-family house, little equity but good income, is it at all feasible?11
19.12.2012Suggestion for room layout on the ground floor of a new single-family house26
09.04.2013New single-family house including carport and garage - realistic cost estimate?11
14.09.2013Floor plan/position single-family house, please provide suggestions + tips10
17.11.2013Planning single-family house - building regulations not followed13
26.10.2013Solid house-single family house 142 m² living space, questions about floor plans/building costs27
26.02.2014Single-family house - Is a balcony on the 1st floor sensible?14
18.06.2014Our floor plan design, your opinions20
12.06.2014Walls of a new single-family house, ground floor runs crooked, defect correction construction defect19
25.02.2015Planning / Architect, involvement of specialist planners for the approval plan10
19.03.2015Planning a single-family house with a general contractor or architect or similar28
22.01.2016Once again a floor plan for criticism.34
16.06.2015Floor plan 200 sqm with integrated winter garden and gallery32
26.10.20168x12m floor plan idea search36
06.03.2017Single-family house or semi-detached house?37
30.07.2019Hiring SiGeKo for a single-family house?13
24.02.2019My floor plan for a 4-family house, please share your opinions72
11.05.2024Floor plan & orientation of house on a 420m² plot36
30.08.2024Newly built semi-detached house 155 sqm - orientation & floor plan accordingly59

Oben