Bus system / home installation, looking for advice, cost plan

  • Erstellt am 2012-03-26 23:35:57

Der Da

2012-04-03 16:10:13
  • #1
I will also do it alone, and only install what really makes sense. For example, it makes no sense to control your oven remotely.
 

Shism

2012-04-03 16:27:11
  • #2


Yeah, there are many more or less crazy examples from manufacturers trying to make the topic appealing...

When I press the button in the kitchen in the morning, the light turns on, the coffee machine starts up, and the internet radio begins to fill the house with my favorite station... The blinds go up and the towel warmer in the bathroom switches to maximum...

But if I just want to turn on the light or skip the radio, it already gets difficult...

Likewise, motion detectors for lighting control in the stairwell... You can do it... but you’ll probably get annoyed more often than you think, especially if you have pets... and you probably won’t save electricity when considering the power consumption of the involved bus components...

Sensible things are automatic shading... retractable blinds during strong winds... automatic control of heating and controlled residential ventilation, detecting open windows... an "all off" switch at the door...

Many things are simply expensive gimmicks that cost electricity and can break...
 

Dominic

2012-04-19 19:05:46
  • #3
here's my two cents on that:

Personally, I don't think much of EIB systems because I don't see their benefit.
"Simple" expandability always involves programming (which costs significantly more per hour than a normal electrician's hour).
For a new socket or switch, you still need the power supply line + bus line. So also more costs.

Just google "Siemens Logo" – it provides at least the same functions for much less cost.
It should just be installed centrally (e.g., in the meter box).
The cable routing must be adapted here, but you don't need bus lines for that.
 

Der Da

2012-04-19 19:56:16
  • #4
Wuha ... I programmed PLC controls until I was sick of it during my studies You don't even want to hear my pain-er hourly rate
 

Dominic

2012-04-19 20:15:05
  • #5
hehe a Logo is also just a PLC in mini format. However, I think the functions are more than enough for roller shutter control, lighting control, etc. If you then combine it with a nice touch panel or two, it's already a nice thing. (mein Geschmack !) And above all, a switch doesn't cost 100 € then
 

Shism

2012-04-25 15:43:35
  • #6


---> Decentralized <--- that is the main advantage of EIP compared to a PLC solution.



Programming yourself? You have to do that with the PLC as well...



My main pain with such solutions: if the PLC dies, then nothing works for you! No lights, no shutters, etc.... How long does such a PLC last under continuous use? It can last 10 years... it can die after 5... or after 15... will you still get suitable replacements then?

If a participant dies in EIP, then all the others continue to work without errors...
 

Similar topics
15.10.2013electric roller shutters / switch17
21.05.2015Can roller shutters with switches be retrofitted for wireless control?14
31.12.2015Preparing electrical work for a smart home new construction17
21.11.2018Switch for roller shutters on the window or on the door?38
21.12.2018Roller shutters with a switch and central timer, is that possible?23
22.05.2019Switch / Button / Double Button / Dimmer / Eltako19
05.08.2020Electrical installation - Retrofit switches/buttons wirelessly26
12.02.2021Retrofitting FI switches, older electronics18
28.03.2022Replace switch with light - wiring13
28.02.2023Motion detector instead of switch?19
19.04.2023Smart home without switches? P.Hue, Home Assistant, Homematic wired IP53
06.09.2024Difference between dim switch and dim button?15

Oben