2 offers for a single-family house in MV, large difference, is the offer plausible?

  • Erstellt am 2017-12-30 12:44:33

11ant

2018-01-01 20:06:17
  • #1


4. For the hatch where the chimney sweep climbs out, I wouldn’t get worked up.
11. With this construction and execution, many mistakes can be made; insulation thickness alone says little.
 

Baumfachmann

2018-01-01 20:26:31
  • #2
Roof insulation is necessary in any case, even when installing an insulated window
 

Nordlys

2018-01-01 20:28:42
  • #3
Why necessary? We have insulated the top floor ceiling, but not the attic. It is cold in winter, warm in summer, dry, airy. Okay for storage. Why insulate?
 

Baumfachmann

2018-01-01 21:06:42
  • #4
Only the ceiling is cheaper, the roof is insulated as well, that's just the best standard
 

Nordlys

2018-01-01 21:34:26
  • #5
well. Belts and suspenders. Very German....that's why houses are so expensive here.
 

bau.mal

2018-01-02 11:38:08
  • #6

The spread can even be larger.


I would avoid such people; they like to leave you out in the cold when you need them.


What you posted from both construction service descriptions is incomplete and therefore not comparable. You would need to know the exact wording, but you can hardly expect that from laypeople here.

From experience, I would guess that you have chosen two providers who could not be more extreme. Even if the design deviates from the usual—less so because it disguises a recessed top floor, but because of the many recesses—the price probably lies in the middle. I would discard both and not consider them further.

There are many providers in MV as well; go to new development areas and talk to homeowners there, ask them about their experiences, or find a supervising architect. But make sure to ask for references.
 

Similar topics
25.05.2015Extractor hood / roof or wall14
03.03.2015Insulating the roof with kitchen paper/toilet paper12
24.05.2015KfW 55 with wooden house - U-values: Wall 0.18 - Roof 0.1617
05.05.2016Insulate the roof: flakes, panels or wool17
07.03.2020Children's room on the upper floor open up to the roof25
20.09.2016Extending walls beyond the roof?!43
10.03.2017Roof design / Use of 2nd floor mandatory with 2 full floors23
20.10.2017Roof with photovoltaic or other investment, any experiences?19
12.09.2017Roof constructed too flat - Construction company does not acknowledge the defect12
21.10.2017Sealing the base slab before the roof is installed19
20.04.2018Roof covered with fake tiles - house accepted.12
29.10.2018Roof, flat roof, gable roof, shed roof - How much does each cost?22
25.03.2019Ceiling suddenly too small for controlled residential ventilation!54
02.07.2019Purlin distance from exterior wall or roof16
02.12.2019Single-family house (2 floors + residential basement + developed attic) approximately 200 sqm - changes162
07.12.2019Bank guarantee from the roofer due to defects in the roof16
27.02.2020Is the vapor barrier in the roof vapor-permeable? Yes? No!16
10.04.2020Rainwater from the roof - drainage in the soil for discharge?12
14.02.2021Re-roofing, roof tiles not possible45
16.01.2023Full rafter insulation roof or insulation on concrete slab40

Oben