We also had a hard time choosing new tiles and after 2 years of searching we finally got our tiles last month, but I wouldn’t have thought of asking for opinions in the forum. In the end, it has to please you, not strangers. Over the 2 years, we also changed our minds about the color several times and in the end we pragmatically chose a tile on which you can see dog hair the least.
Dear DaGoodness, Thank you very much for your honest answer I thought I was the only one who keeps changing her mind... I just asked the crowd but of course posted possible tiles that we like. So maybe it’s not completely wrong. Of course, we ultimately decide ourselves. My husband currently prefers the cooler one. For me, the tile could still have more dark/light contrasts within itself