Trench collector brine-water heat pump or air-water heat pump?

  • Erstellt am 2015-03-01 10:25:05

tabtab

2016-06-03 14:21:46
  • #1
Yes, it actually did stand, but we were made aware of geocollect by our heating engineer. Just google it, I’m not allowed to link it here. It sounds interesting and would at least be an installation done by the heating installer.

I wouldn’t state that a brine system is ALWAYS better than an air-water heat pump like that. Take a look at the Vitocal 300a values in practice. Some of them have a seasonal performance factor above 4.5. And I’ve already seen brine pumps that don’t reach that value. There isn’t that much difference nowadays. And the much higher investment in drilling probably won’t pay off within a lifetime with a 0.5 lower seasonal performance factor ratio. I find trench collectors interesting but too uncertain. That’s why now considering geocollect. But I think in the end I’ll save the money and rather put photovoltaic panels on the roof. You get more return.
 

Sebastian79

2016-06-03 14:27:59
  • #2
Sole heat pumps that are worse than an air pump are simply set up terribly or the overall system is not right. An annual performance factor over 4.5 with air pumps? Not even BAFA agrees with their great calculation - you also have to look at where the people live, whether they have anything additional.

So first of all, hard to believe...
 

oleda222

2016-06-03 14:32:01
  • #3
I used mine to heat the screed in winter and therefore don’t have any reasonable data on normal consumption yet. I also haven’t had time to properly evaluate the consumption for hot water.
 

Sebastian79

2016-06-03 14:37:47
  • #4
Oh yes, during the screed heating I had an annual performance factor of 1.9
 

tabtab

2016-06-03 14:55:36
  • #5


Then, for example, take a look at the Ochsner Eagle – it is specified with 4.5 right from the factory.
 

Sebastian79

2016-06-03 15:01:56
  • #6
Could it be that you confused Cop and Jahresarbeitszahl
 

Similar topics
26.10.2012External perimeter insulation floor slab, basement mold risk11
09.05.2015Ground source heat pump vs. air source heat pump24
27.07.2015New building heating?13
19.06.2015Build according to KFW 70 or the Energy Saving Ordinance 201442
19.05.2021Experiences with brine heat pump491
02.12.2016Air-Water Heat Pump - Experiences22
06.12.2015Heat pump / final energy demand / annual performance factor20
17.12.2015Is T8 Poroton only significantly better than T12 in heating costs?14
18.10.2016Which heat pump? Ventilation system / Air-to-water heat pump93
03.04.2018Building a single-family house in NRW103
06.06.2018Air heat pump in combination with water-carrying fireplace18
31.05.2018Air-water heat pump including ventilation system vs. brine heat pump including ventilation system15
13.06.2018Energy consultant for a KfW 70 house costs 2,500€?29
25.03.2019Heating concept for single-family house new build approx. 190m²: Split heat pump vs. ground source (brine)13
19.11.2019KFW40 or better in solid construction, possible without additional insulation?58
24.01.2020Annual performance factor calculation for funding (parameters and calculation tool)29
27.01.2020KFW40 House Project 2020 *Planning Ideas*32
13.01.2021Comparison of geothermal heat pump with LWW pump86
15.12.2022Electricity consumption at home, what is your consumption?418
11.02.2025KFW 40, Ground-water heat pump worthwhile or is air-water better?15

Oben