But you really seem to be comparing apples and oranges there. You also don’t expect a BMW to cost the same as a Dacia. I’m not saying that Dacia is bad. But you have to decide whether you want "some" Amazon parts or branded products from a specialist dealer. It’s up to everyone themselves.
Your comparison with car brands is a bit off, of course there is also a lot of belief involved, but there are also many hard facts (resale value of certain brands, lifespan, inventory, technical performance, etc.). The car market is definitely much more thoroughly examined.
Apart from the valid argument of the advantages of professional installation (expert installation, warranty), I haven’t read many hard facts about material selection here.
It therefore seems more like a risk decision. With the additional cost you take less risk, since the rain shower will probably work and if not, you have the warranty. If you trust yourself to do it on your own, you don’t have a warranty in case of doubt but get the same result for much less money.