Real estate financing - the jungle of offers ...

  • Erstellt am 2017-01-06 16:15:35

LinaLustig

2017-01-06 16:15:35
  • #1
Hello dear forum, dear forum members,

I registered here today in the hope of getting a few tips regarding my upcoming construction financing.

The situation is a bit special: I am single, childless, mid-30s. I studied, have been working on my doctoral thesis for several years now and am working "on the side," about 40% in employment with 1600 euros gross and also as a freelancer. For several years I have had a medical diagnosis that has the potential to limit my ability to work or possibly completely negate it in the long term (might be, but doesn’t have to be). I have disability insurance based on my current income, and legal insurance as well.

Since my situation has been causing me great concern for some time, I would like to buy a property. My parents have been supporting me financially so far; depending on how my health develops, I will probably have to abandon my doctoral thesis or still finish it. In any case, I will then work more – either as an employee or by expanding my freelance activity.

For me, due to my situation, any rent (which is not cheap for me now) is money thrown away, because I want to secure myself. Unfortunately, I have no equity – let’s put it this way: everything was planned differently…

My parents, both retirees (pension together about 4200 euros net), are willing to support me with the house purchase, also financially. The family owns two paid-off properties: on the one hand, the parental home, which should be completely excluded from any financing, and additionally a condominium (built in the early nineties, permanently maintained and with a solid long-term rental relationship), minimum estimated value 200,000 euros (located in the Stuttgart area, which has experienced immense price increases in recent years – trend is therefore rather upwards). Selling the apartment would be possible, but I want to prevent that because the apartment also offers a certain security regarding my parents and possible health problems.

I have no idea about construction financing; for my parents, it has been too long, so: our knowledge is limited to non-existent.

I have already contacted several mortgage brokers, both by phone and email; two personal meetings have also taken place.

For now, it concerns a specific property that I will take a closer look at these days and would like to buy if everything fits. The house is from the 18th century, is not under monument protection, the building fabric is very good. The roof is okay but already a few years old. The windows are less than 10 years old. It was completely gutted; all lines and connections were renewed, i.e., the following work is now pending:
- Laying flooring on the ground floor (preferred: exposed screed)
- complete electrical work (= sockets, lighting – the lines are already laid)
- new plaster (ceiling)
- possibly impregnating timber beams inside (don’t know if anything has been done here yet)
- sanding and treating floorboards upstairs
- attic expansion (insulation and making ready for living) including floorboard treatment similar to upstairs
- installation of heating (which one? no idea yet)
- installation of bathroom & toilet including floor (preferred: exposed screed)
- installation of kitchen including floor (preferred: exposed screed)

Architect, energy consultant, craftsmen will still be brought in before the final purchase contract, of course.

Purchase price including broker, notary, property tax – approx. 75,000 euros
Renovation costs estimated at approx. 65,000 euros

I now have several offers and really don’t understand because the advisors’ statements sometimes contradict each other significantly.
For example, it was stated that KfW products are not an option because I probably cannot upgrade the energy efficiency of the house (currently 300 ergo shortly before "shoot me dead") to modern new build standards with my financial means. Another advisor pointed out that some KfW products would be suitable (individual energy measures without the requirement for overall energy efficiency on new-build level, home ownership subsidy).

So far concrete:
1.) Offer 1 from a Volksbank via broker from Dr. Klein (personal meeting):
141,000 euros – 1.42% nominal interest fixed for 10 years, 1.5% repayment with option to increase (must be, of course, is much too low, but would initially give me some breathing room considering my situation, plus special repayments of over 5% possible)
Broker recommends building savings contract for security after the period expires
Borrower: only me, secured by mortgage (family apartment)
2.) Offer 2 and 3 via broker from Interhyp (personal meeting):
DSL Bank and Commerzbank with slightly different conditions – recommendation is Commerzbank (due to local branches and the special nature of the property I want to buy)
Split: loan (90,000 euros) plus KfW product (home ownership subsidy – 50,000 euros); the KfW product is always set for 10 years in every model.
Model 1 – 15 years fixed nominal interest --> DSL Bank 1.99%, Commerzbank 2.12%
Model 2 – 20 years fixed nominal interest --> DSL Bank 2.2%, Commerzbank 2.52%
Borrowers: family (all three), secured by mortgage.
3.) Offer 4 via Enderlein (by phone and email, not yet fully finalized): 72,000 via DSL Bank with 20 years fixed nominal interest 2.04%, approx. 50,000 via KfW spread over two products not further clear to me with fixed nominal interest of 0.78% and 0.93%. Amount is still set too low; it was the first broker I chose – before I roughly calculated the renovation costs with a “knowledgeable” acquaintance.

In addition, there was a suggestion of a simple capital procurement with the comment that this would involve less formalities (difficult valuation of the property to be purchased in its current condition, certified list of renovation costs by a professional, etc.).

Can someone give me their assessment based on these details? I would be very grateful :)

Many kind regards!
 

HilfeHilfe

2017-01-06 16:25:24
  • #2
Hello,

I am personally sorry about your illness in your young years, separate from the object and the very good financial circumstances of your parents. What do the brokers and the house bank say about your personal income?

1600 gross + amount X from freelance work is not enough for this project.
 

LinaLustig

2017-01-06 16:41:29
  • #3
Thank you for the kind words:)

My income is clearly not sufficient at the moment. However, this has not been a problem with the above-mentioned offers so far - either due to three borrowers and/or the mortgage regarding the apartment.

Offer No. 1 and 4 completely exclude the parents in this respect - why I would still receive money does not fully make sense to me ;) Sure - the apartment, the existing one, is worth more than the requested loan, but there is still the mortgage credit directive ... No idea, maybe its interpretation is variable? That's the only way I can explain it.
 

HilfeHilfe

2017-01-06 17:20:01
  • #4
Then ask, an offer is not the same as a financing commitment. Especially since you want to exclude your parents. Unfortunately, it won't work without them.
 

LinaLustig

2017-01-06 17:37:07
  • #5
No, I don’t want to exclude my parents :) As I said - everything is possible for us.

Regarding the topic [Angebot ungleich Zusage]: All key data was entered truthfully everywhere (and really very extensively and thoroughly recorded). In this respect, with certain constellations (such as only me as the borrower), some providers were excluded anyway. However, I do think that if I disclose everything completely and the offers are then shown to the broker (including those that are not available with explanations why not), then I assume - similar to insurance, account openings, loans in general - that the offer will be confirmed upon verification of all data - or am I seeing this incorrectly?
 

Alex85

2017-01-06 18:24:38
  • #6
Quite different: Depending on the medical condition and its usual course, I would consider whether investing the money in a property is actually the right choice. It's no use sitting in your own walls but not being able to fill the fridge due to lack of workforce. Meaning, liquidity can be very important and would then unfortunately be tied up in a property.
 

Similar topics
01.11.2019Buying property - How to proceed? Realtor, bank, owner?15
11.08.2020House purchase with construction loan repayment rate42
26.08.2021Our financial situation - Your opinion?209
12.02.2022Forward loan for 09/2024 - accept or wait?47
31.03.2022Process schedule at Commerzbank for construction financing28
14.06.2022KfW BEG funding stopped 261, 262, 263, 264, 461, 463, 4641239
07.01.2024KfW Funding Climate-Friendly Residential Building from March 2023152
08.08.2024Where are the ECB's key interest rates heading?85
16.02.2024Property in good condition financable?90
06.07.2024Loan brokerage through the broker11

Oben