Developer does not want to offset lump-sum damages with installments

  • Erstellt am 2020-07-11 16:48:05

Gerd1908

2020-07-11 16:48:05
  • #1
Hello everyone,

In December 2017, we signed a builder contract for a turnkey semi-detached house with land. Completion was planned for December 2018. We set an extension of one month and received confirmation that we are entitled to the contractually agreed lump-sum damages of €60 per day since the beginning of January 2019.

Now it is mid-July 2020 and the construction is not finished, the builder is not insolvent and is financed through a financial service provider. Of 7 installments, 3 are still outstanding.
As lump-sum damages, more than €30,000 have accumulated, but the builder refuses to offset this against special requests and insists on full payment of all installments. When the construction is finished, they would reimburse the damages either by direct payment or through the guarantee (which is only €25,000). However, we suspect that we will never see the amount and that the builder will immediately file for insolvency after receiving all installments.
To date, we still have €60,000 "open" which the builder would receive with the last 3 installments, if he had completed regularly within 2018.

Does anyone know such cases and can recommend a course of action?
We believe that as soon as we do not pay an installment, the builder threatens insolvency.
 

HilfeHilfe

2020-07-11 16:55:22
  • #2
The problem is that he is currently not continuing construction, correct?
 

Gerd1908

2020-07-11 16:59:06
  • #3
No, construction is slowly progressing. Construction started in April 2018. In October 2018 there was a construction stop because the craftsmen (bricklayers) were not paid. Then it continued from April 2019 until November 2019. Then another construction stop due to flimsy reasons (probably no money). In April 2020 it continued and so far it looks like completion in August, if all craftsmen are paid and they get it organized properly... So far we have paid all installments in full to prevent further stops.
 

nordanney

2020-07-11 17:05:39
  • #4
That will be a legal issue. Offset possible or not. Does your contract say anything? How does the compensation come about?
 

Gerd1908

2020-07-11 17:12:03
  • #5
The flat-rate compensation results from the delay of now 1.5 years and is fixed in the contract at €60 per day of delay. From the environment of the developer, it is said that before paying compensation to all buyers, they would rather shut the business down. With another GmbH from the group of companies, which only built on third-party land and lost the contract here due to several construction stoppages (termination by landowners), the GmbH was sold to a company liquidator, renamed (+ appointed a new managing director) and has now filed for insolvency. The registered office of the sold and re-registered GmbH did not exist (I personally checked).
 

Gerd1908

2020-07-11 17:33:53
  • #6
As a supplement: The developer acknowledged the damages compensation when setting the grace period and already requested at the 2nd installment not to reduce the installments in order to avoid construction delays (in hindsight, this is of course just ridiculous).

I was only able to edit my last post once.
 

Similar topics
16.06.2011Conclude a construction contract under reservation?10
13.09.2012Feeling pressured into a contract, is that normal?17
13.06.2015New construction with developer / construction drawing documents23
18.01.2016Payment of final installment and acceptance44
16.02.2016Question about contractual completion14
15.03.2016Developer changes plot size25
16.03.2016Single-family house - developer rejected25
10.09.2016Construction financing and contract with the developer24
21.07.2017Buying a terraced house from a developer - contract content?71
30.12.2017Take over the insurance from the developer after handover of keys?15
29.05.2018Buying a house from a developer - required documents33
30.08.2019Must developers indicate immense embankment height/costs?12
04.03.2019Client-side while building with a property developer16
06.01.2020House purchase, prefabricated house from the developer with land10
29.07.2020How to secure like ETW from the property developer24
13.09.2020BAFA funding for heat pump (air-to-water heat pump) when building with a developer25
01.07.2022Construction delay without completion. The house simply is not finished21
19.03.2023Consumer construction contract, construction contract not executed - compensation for damages?44
25.12.2023Behavior in case of imminent delay by the property developer48

Oben