Base slab in water -> Alternatives to WU concrete?

  • Erstellt am 2020-02-15 11:31:54

derbasti1896

2020-02-15 11:31:54
  • #1
Hello and good good day!
I am new to the forum and signed up because I have a question about our construction project:

We are building a single-family house in the Südheide. Timber frame construction, 1 1/2 stories, 170 m² living space.
The soil survey showed that the groundwater in the built-up area stands at 1.2 to 1.0 m. A borehole next to the built-up area showed 0.9 m. On top of the topsoil follows fluviatile sand, gray --> medium sand, fine sandy, slightly coarse sandy.

Originally, a slab with frost skirt was planned (thermal foundation slab with PE foil against ground moisture). After the geologist and the architect had another conversation, I was advised to invest in a slab made of WU concrete. It would - since in the worst case a groundwater level several decimeters higher is to be expected - mean that the foundation stands in water. Therefore WU concrete. +10 cm higher slab, the cost is over + 8,000€.

The additional costs add up (obviously) and I would like - if possible - further assessments on the topic.

My first question:
What are your experiences? Is the slab actually threatened to stand in water, or is the geologist being too cautious?

Second question:
If the concern that the slab could temporarily lie in water is correct, are there reasonable alternatives to a WU concrete slab?
Of course, I am willing to do and spend what is technically necessary to protect my values in the long term. But I am curious for input.

Many thanks and have a nice weekend everyone!

Regards
Sebastian
 

Grinsekatze

2020-02-15 12:25:51
  • #2
I do not find that too cautious. We still have drought in the Südheide. Entire lakes have dried up here. If that normalizes again, the groundwater level will surely be higher!
 

face26

2020-02-15 13:12:38
  • #3
...so at Lake Constance people have already had experience with pile dwellings

I'm not an expert, but I think you don't have many options. If you find anyone at all who will build it differently for you, they will surely not take any liability in case water ingress occurs. And honestly?
It might be that nothing ever happens, but with all the extreme weather conditions, maybe next year the water will already be that high, do you really want to ask yourself then why you skimped on the measure recommended by the expert?
 

derbasti1896

2020-02-19 05:25:12
  • #4
I obviously see it the same way, see my last paragraph. Savings are only made at this point if it does not affect stability, durability, and warranty in any way.

Are there alternatives to the chosen WU floor slab?

Thanks and regards
 

Similar topics
05.06.2010Basement made of high perforated bricks or concrete?11
22.12.2016Is rain harmful to concrete slabs?12
20.08.2016Base slab vs strip foundation15
06.10.2016Base plate with defects?22
10.07.2017WU concrete + flush-mounted boxes in the residential basement - how can this be solved?35
15.03.2018When is a slope a slope? Basement vs. slab19
18.08.2017Base plate ready - construction supervisor absent20
06.10.2019Base plate with concrete core activation. What is your opinion?46
05.04.2018Water on ground slab, cause and leak unknown24
07.01.2019House with slab foundation on a slope52
09.02.2019Ground slab with strip foundation and frost skirt23
14.10.2019Dampness in the basement on the floor slab and walls25
16.04.2020Pour the ground slab in sections?19
27.05.2020Set formwork blocks on the foundation or in concrete21
30.06.2020Base plate, too little cement in the concrete19
12.11.2020Formwork blocks on the foundation slab in a mortar bed or not?13
25.05.2022Cistern - flat tank or round tank - groundwater12
17.01.2023Sealing transition between ground slab and wall to the soil15
22.02.2023Soil report for bungalow 140 sqm, additional costs for WU concrete?33
14.01.2023Internal heat pump in the basement not possible due to groundwater?37

Oben