The bank may want a construction service description despite individual subcontract awarding

  • Erstellt am 2017-11-29 17:34:59

ruppsn

2017-11-30 12:48:11
  • #1
I would say that the approach is the right one, that suits you and leads to the goal. At least I did not mean that "our" approach is more correct than another, or especially yours :-)

Under the premise that it is also built accordingly, perhaps. Experience shows, however, that in the dynamic design process there can be frequent shifts, so that the basis for the offer changes. For example, you remember that you want another window, which may require changes to the statics, possibly requiring a beam. Suddenly, some controlled residential ventilation pipes can no longer run where you would like them to, because they would cross the beam. On the basis of which steel quantities, which controlled residential ventilation components, which window (dimensions), etc. were the offers then made, and what significance do they still have?

Another example: One wants, since budget-wise after assigning the shell construction and roofer it is still feasible, a KNX bus system, which entails significantly more cabling effort. The ventilation pipes limit the routing of the empty conduits or these can no longer be laid in the concrete ceiling, but on the shell construction ceiling. This possibly makes a different floor structure with liquid insulation necessary -> different cost structure.

You try to be as precise as possible in the specifications to have cost control. It is no coincidence that different levels of accuracy for cost estimation, calculation, and determination are required according to HOAI and the service phases.

At the end of the day, only what works for you personally counts :-)
 

ruppsn

2017-11-30 13:01:56
  • #2


Oh, that’s interesting. You live "where it’s nice," so in Fürth? [emoji6][emoji23]

Yes, it would surely be interesting, but probably also depends a bit on the building project [emoji4]
 

Zaba12

2017-11-30 13:06:56
  • #3


Interesting examples: We don’t need this flexibility, why would we, everything fundamental is pre-planned. Upgrades for bathrooms and electrical as well as tiles are buffered.

But if you put such "eggs in the basket" for your architect where, for example, because you decided on the tiled shower only after the screed was laid, then the screed can only be "broken out" at that spot. So some fundamental aspects should already be fixed. Whether you want KNX is clear beforehand anyway. The later you intervene in the planning, the more expensive it becomes.
 

Zaba12

2017-11-30 13:10:14
  • #4

No, I live about 20 km around Fürth. It’s nice there :-)

We can exchange via the "conversation function" if you want.
 

ruppsn

2017-11-30 13:21:48
  • #5
Maybe we are talking past each other. I am talking about changes during the execution planning, i.e., the phase in the house building project where the detailed planning is done. And there are a lot of ideas that you balance with the (remaining budget), so you use the feedback/information from concrete tenders to react “very agilely” to the changing requirements. I have experienced this phase as an iterative design process and feel more comfortable with it than with a waterfall-like up-front planning with some “buffers.” And about KNX. No, precisely not. It is a not insignificant cost factor, just like an air-to-water heat pump or a brine-to-water heat pump. I decide dynamically according to budget, and of course early enough not to cause additional costs. But everyone as they like, I just feel more comfortable with adaptive approaches that respond to changing realities than with waterfall-like planning with buffers...maybe also because of my profession. [emoji6]
 

Zaba12

2017-11-30 13:35:21
  • #6


:-) Seems so.

Even though my concerns were not addressed, it was interesting in the thread. I will get in touch if no construction service description is needed.
 

Similar topics
01.09.2016Is Smarthome KNX automation possible based on the floor plan?81
09.09.2016Controlled residential ventilation and still open windows at night71
06.06.2018Automation of a controlled residential ventilation system (ventilation system)32
01.02.2019Controlled residential ventilation with cooling: brine geothermal heat pump instead of air-to-water heat pump?30
15.10.2020Controlled residential ventilation manufacturer selection - How to approach?43

Oben