We have dark roller shutters but can only report on these first few really warm days of the year so far. First of all, I can say that they really help. It even feels like they help more when the slats are 50% open, i.e., horizontal. That way you can still have a nice view outside. Of course, the house heats up, that's inevitable, but we have a complete south orientation with very large windows and it still remains pleasantly cool in comparison. We have no comparison when it comes to the color. Ours is RAL 9007, aluminum gray. However, I don’t think it would make much of a difference. We haven’t noticed any creaking or anything similar so far. But as I said, it is also the first year in the house.