Is a solid house energetically much worse than a wooden house?

  • Erstellt am 2024-01-24 09:43:37

Harakiri

2024-01-24 12:05:15
  • #1


Well, let’s put it this way: just as with thermal insulation (it is somewhat more difficult to achieve excellent values in solid construction), it is the opposite with soundproofing (it is somewhat more difficult to achieve very high standards in timber frame construction). But both are doable.
 

Rübe1

2024-01-24 12:53:06
  • #2


I can achieve reasonable soundproofing in all types of construction; it depends on what and how it is built. Or do you seriously want to compare aerated concrete with KSL? And then put a properly designed timber frame construction next to it, you will be surprised.
 

Tolentino

2024-01-24 15:27:28
  • #3
Be very grateful to the pentagonal construction manager friend, because now you know with whom you definitely will not build.

The previous speakers have already answered in more detail.

What can already be said is that a low-energy house or even passive house standard can be achieved more cheaply with a timber frame house (not necessarily will be) than with solid construction. And that with solid construction, if extra insulation of the exterior walls is to be avoided (monolithic construction, which many prefer), an increase in the exterior wall thickness accompanies a higher standard, which can be seen as a disadvantage by some.
 

11ant

2024-01-24 19:18:03
  • #4

The "arguments" of the biased specialists (who are otherwise more salespeople than site managers) regularly differ only in wording but not in "quality." I can only agree to keep a five-corner distance from this gentleman (and perhaps to thank him for the warning not to flirt with this provider).

In general, I advise all prospective builders to decide on the construction method as follows: first, to preliminarily plan the house with a self-chosen architect, and before entering the refinement to the design planning, approach four to five providers (two timber builders, two masons, and possibly one more from any faction) openly regarding what this design (and optionally a similar design from their standard catalog) would roughly cost. From the feedback, one then derives conclusions and lets the insights flow into the further design process. Typical results of this round are:
X) one of the construction methods is (for the respective design, which can never be generalized) significantly cheaper
Y) it’s (as usually) more or less the same either way
Z) knowing early on that you need more money or have to be more modest.


Did you give a robotic mower a sports exhaust, or does it beep like a garbage truck when reversing?
 

ypg

2024-01-24 21:15:24
  • #5
hm.. with insulated timber panel construction you can also have good soundproofing, and just like a Kfw55 house in solid construction only consumes 55%, a house in timber panel construction consumes 55%

But it doesn't matter:

Here you are being manipulated, and that is not the proper way. Build regionally with whatever you want.
 

11ant

2024-01-25 01:15:12
  • #6
I explicitly wrote "Mähroböterle" - the change did NOT come from me!!!
 

Similar topics
15.11.2011Poor sound insulation to the outside in thermal insulation bricks16
17.05.2016Which interior wall material/wall thickness provides good sound insulation?22
13.05.2016Brick T9/T10/T11/T12? Thermal insulation vs. sound insulation21
28.11.2016Is sound insulation according to DIN standard 4109 relevant for building permits?16
30.09.2021Sound insulation - differences in interior doors?40
14.11.2016Soundproofing - weakest link? (Windows?)26
23.08.2017What is the difference in sound insulation between a solid house and a prefabricated house?27
19.07.2018Sound insulation: Thickness of cavity insulation for interior wall?10
09.08.2018Fence as sound insulation towards the neighbor. What inhibits sound the best?27
01.02.2021Y-Tong (aerated concrete) - quality building material? (sound insulation!)91
07.11.2018Is it sufficient as sound insulation according to DIN4109 in a single-family house?11
23.06.2019Little sound insulation in the solid house - what could be the reason?10
01.11.2020Prefabricated house, poor sound insulation85
07.03.2020Door frame not fitting / no sound insulation20
25.01.2020Which material is suitable for the shell construction (thermal and sound insulation)?20
18.07.2021Unfilled bricks and soundproofing - looking for experiences36
14.05.2020Sound insulation VDI Guideline 4100 & DIN 4109 in prefabricated house construction49
23.06.2020Solid wood house - sound insulation, heat protection18

Oben