Contractor / Alternative Subfirma

  • Erstellt am 2020-03-26 12:19:53

alive&kicking

2020-03-26 12:19:53
  • #1
Hello everyone,
I would like to ask a question here for which I have not been able to find an answer or assessment anywhere so far.

We are building with a larger company from abroad, which also operates a company here in Germany, with which we have concluded the contract (VOB) covering the trades roofing, drywall, ETICS/plaster, and screed, in addition to the shell construction. The original planning by the contractor envisaged, although it is not part of the contract, partly deploying workers from the country of origin.

Status of these works:
Shell construction completed, windows installed, some work still to be done on the roof, e.g. metal sheet work and some minor corrections, interior finishing has begun.

Local companies have been commissioned for house electrics, sanitary/heating. The basic installations for the above-mentioned trades are almost completed.

Due to the restricted entry regulations caused by the Corona pandemic, it is currently not possible for the workers from abroad to complete the now pending tasks, such as drywall and ETICS.

Since an end to the restrictions is not foreseeable and although we basically want to continue working with the company, the question naturally arises as to how the house construction can be completed in a reasonable time, especially since construction operations on German construction sites have not yet been interrupted.

The current situation is unique and I fear that I will not get a definitive answer here either. But … maybe answering the following question helps, if it is transferable..

To what extent is a German construction company, which has taken over a contract like ours, required to provide replacement in the event of a subcontractor’s failure? Is there a usual timeframe here?

Basically, I assume that the company must indeed look for/offer alternatives in order to meet the construction schedule, but what impact could this have on additional costs? Or is it similar here to unexpectedly increased material procurement costs, which the contractor also has to bear, if I am correctly informed?

Most likely there are also points I have not thought of. I am thankful for any tips.

Thank you very much and all the best
 

HilfeHilfe

2020-03-26 12:39:42
  • #2
You are like everyone else in Germany. Everyone wants to finish their house construction and reasonable companies have fully booked order books.

Do you seriously think your German construction company has a chance to provide replacements in the current situation?

Do you have anything about contractual penalties in the contract? Although I think Corona counts as force majeure and thus any clause would become invalid.
 

ypg

2020-03-26 12:48:39
  • #3
Yes, everything is rubbish!


Which company, which country, which law applies? Surely not a German one? Or is it? Read the fine print - GTC



what deadline was agreed upon?
In case of frost, storm, and flooding, the times are suspended, meaning taken out of the agreed construction period due to force majeure. The company does not have to provide any compensation for that.



reasonable is subjective here. Delays in construction must always be expected... we have just been born into a comfort zone. We know no hardships, everything has to run as we like. We don’t even wait a week anymore for a package... okay, I’m digressing.
 

ypg

2020-03-26 12:50:38
  • #4
If the workers cannot work (I hope there are not too many construction projects in Germany or abroad), then I would be more concerned about the company's bankruptcy, which would then also be a problem for you.
 

Osnabruecker

2020-03-26 13:10:22
  • #5
Force majeure --> You have to accept longer construction times. But, as it is a VOB contract, in my opinion there are no monetary effects for you caused by the company. However, you are left bearing the costs (interest, longer rent) yourself.
 

alive&kicking

2020-03-26 14:51:12
  • #6
Wow, thanks for the many answers in such a short time!

I’ll answer from top to bottom:

- we are already looking for replacement companies in parallel; completely unexpected from our side, we already have offers from several firms. Strange, maybe a lot has gotten mixed up.
- Of course, we have no contractual penalties included, which, as you also write, wouldn’t hold up


- German GmbH
- Completion of remaining work by the end of 2019, we were generous with that anyway and now it’s breaking our neck. That’s why we are also looking for alternative solutions, including with the company.
- well, that’s obviously a risk for many

@ Osnabrücker
- that’s the question whether force majeure is an argument when other firms are available

and thus also to my posed question, how it would be under normal circumstances. So does a contracting company have to provide a replacement?
 

Similar topics
14.11.2011Shell construction still this year15
28.02.2015Cost difference between KSK+WDVS and aerated concrete11
27.02.2015Purchase shell construction and complete it including financing15
11.02.2016Cost per cubic meter of built-up shell space14
07.05.2016Buying a shell construction - Experiences21
06.09.2017Add a wind catch later to the shell construction17
07.10.2017From when must the shell construction be dry or sealed?16
28.03.2021Window installation WDVS - When can the window fitter take measurements?24
10.08.2018Rough estimate of construction costs for 220 sqm92
14.07.2019Costs for the shell construction of an office building16
05.09.2019What must be decided regarding the facade before the shell construction?10
27.10.2019Water in the inner frame: Shoddy construction? (Shell construction)15
21.11.2019Shell construction contract: contract penalties, security deposits, payments?17
28.05.2020Buy a 25-year-old shell structure42
11.06.2020Sand-lime brick + ETICS, Ytong or sand-lime brick 2-layer14
20.02.2021Exterior wall for KFW 40 (+) with or without ETICS?86
09.05.2021Interior walls made of drywall or masonry?18
09.07.2021Is the construction time specified in the prefabricated house contract binding?19
06.06.2023Estimation of construction time for the new build of a semi-detached house17
28.03.2024Offer for shell construction of a single-family house 170 sqm - Is the price market-appropriate?57

Oben