Bought an old cellar. Does it only carry wooden studs or also solid construction?

  • Erstellt am 2020-09-09 22:44:32

Lumpi_LE

2020-09-10 13:59:31
  • #1
You need the structural engineer anyway, so why speculate about it now?
 

11ant

2020-09-10 14:05:59
  • #2

I see it similarly – for the house at that time, it was probably an adequate substitute for the originally planned masonry basement. Whether it is the same for a larger (taller) house now, well, ask the structural engineer. I would cautiously assume that he would advise positioning the load-bearing walls of the ground floor effectively in alignment with the wall layouts of the basement.
 

OlliQueck

2020-09-10 14:17:34
  • #3
Okay, well I don’t have a single structural engineer on hand since we didn’t want to award the trades separately but rather build with a general contractor. I’m afraid I will end up paying for structural engineering twice – first a structural engineer to calculate which houses can be placed + then with the contractor everything will be structurally planned again for the actual house construction.
 

OlliQueck

2020-09-10 14:19:51
  • #4
Yeah, the new house wouldn’t be bigger or taller, just a different construction method – solid instead of wood.
 

11ant

2020-09-10 15:53:37
  • #5
You said a solid construction builder was concerned that the basement would only support a single story, without a developed attic. And I say, if the static calculation at that time was only designed for a one-and-a-half-story prefab house of that era, you have to expect that even a prefab house of current design is already heavier and would have to be reduced. The times when timber frame panel houses were lightweight are history. An energy saving ordinance "prefab house" has about 29 cm wall thickness, not 16 as it was back then.
 

OlliQueck

2020-09-10 16:00:35
  • #6
Hm okay, we hadn’t thought that far. I wasn’t even aware that timber studs have developed like that! Good point. That’s right, in the ground floor plan (see attachment) the walls back then are specified as 16cm. Oh dear.. Well, if it’s only enough for a ground floor, then we’ll find something suitable! Now I’m curious what the first prefab house suppliers will say about it. So far, only this solid builder has commented on it.
 

Similar topics
01.03.2011Cost of architect services for prefabricated house13
18.05.2011Minimum scope of services Architect + structural engineer possibly self-performance?10
30.05.2012Massive house costs KFW 70 - Prefabricated house65
27.02.2013Turnkey prefabricated house - total price okay?59
26.12.2012Prefabricated house / solid house, which construction companies?16
27.05.2013Cost estimation: prefabricated house, basement, carport, single garage10
02.09.2013Which heating system for prefab houses: air source heat pump, geothermal, solar, photovoltaic17
05.07.2013Solid house or prefabricated house? Which suits us better?18
23.06.2014Prefabricated house or solid construction - what is your opinion?45
25.06.2014Financial requirements for building a prefabricated house55
12.08.2014Construction method: Prefabricated house Solid house Construction supervisor Architectural planning18
29.09.2014200-300 sqm prefabricated house or passive house? Manufacturer? Construction company?29
06.02.2015Differences between prefabricated houses and alternatives?!18
22.02.2015Solid house vs. prefabricated house12
15.08.2016Civil engineer contradicts structural engineer27
11.01.2018Partition wall thickness for duplex house. Structural engineer plans 17.5 cm14
11.02.2021Structural engineer needed for rough assessment of load-bearing capacity25
09.06.2021House construction planning: solid house or prefabricated house? With or without a basement?80
02.10.2023Floor plan single-family house ~165m² plus basement165
12.01.2025Comprehension question: Gable roof - load-bearing walls - floor plan11

Oben