Walk-in shower in a prefab house, tiles or shower tray?

  • Erstellt am 2022-11-16 10:44:07

jumbo125

2022-11-16 10:44:07
  • #1
Hello everyone

As the topic already says, I am considering whether we should use a shower tray or tiles in our timber frame prefabricated house...
In principle, tiles look better to us, and they are also a bit less slippery.
BUT the issue of water and timber frame is always a bit unpleasant.
Would a shower tray be "safer"?
Thank you
 

i_b_n_a_n

2022-11-16 12:25:14
  • #2
mEA doesn't matter (I have a solid wood house myself). Both properly executed (multiple coats of sealant, corners, etc., separate sealing tape, etc.) will be airtight.
 

Steffi33

2022-11-16 14:04:47
  • #3
I find shower trays somehow more hygienic.. they are bright white and you can see if they are clean… or not. Unfortunately, I have no real idea about the question ;)
 

Tolentino

2022-11-16 14:21:05
  • #4
I think shower trays are somewhat like toilet bowls. If I had the money, I would have also had a tiled washbasin and a tiled bathtub made. That's just how tastes differ.
 

netuser

2022-11-16 15:12:41
  • #5
Exactly, tastes differ and I would never have a tiled sink or bathtub installed :) Shower trays seem to be pretty out, although for example I always find a nice flat tub stylish and not worse than tiled ones. But that is probably not the question here. Rather, we also have a wooden house and at the time had the same considerations as you. With a flat shower tray you can't go wrong and would be on the safe side, or so we thought. In the end, this is exactly where we have our "biggest concern" in the house, because already half a year after moving in we had water damage when water suddenly came through the wooden ceiling in the living room below from under the shower :eek: They searched and initially found nothing, the problem also seemed not reproducible, etc... Finally, it was just a stupid silicone joint that tore at the edge of the shower tray and depending on standing position in the shower, water came through in a rush. That means, the plastic tub gives a bit and the joints are exposed to higher stress! Therefore, I recommend paying utmost attention to good installation stability or rather choosing a metal tub if a tiled floor is not to be chosen. As I said, this point gives me the most concern in the house and I am still considering claiming it as a warranty case. The newly replaced joint has held reliably so far but it is probably only a matter of time until this "maintenance joint" tears again :(
 

i_b_n_a_n

2022-11-16 15:59:52
  • #6

A silicone joint is a maintenance joint. It is allowed to be leaky! Nevertheless, not a single drop should come through. There should be Dichband behind it as a "second waterproof layer."
 

Similar topics
19.10.2008Bathtub vs Shower11
01.01.2010Ground-level pool instead of bathtub?19
14.02.2015Floor-level shower drain with underfloor heating44
14.04.2015Connection of bathtub to shower21
04.09.2015What height bathtub?17
23.09.2015Built-in bathtub - Faucet11
05.07.2016Bathroom planning for a small bathroom with a walk-in shower22
22.07.2016Main bathroom (10 sqm) with open shower, any ideas?84
13.07.2016Bathroom layout with shower11
29.12.2018Renovation tips for a very small bathroom with a shower instead of a bathtub36
05.01.2019Is an electrical cable allowed under the shower?33
25.01.2020walk-in shower size30
06.04.2020Shower - how to close? - brainstorming11
01.02.2021Underfloor heating beneath bathtub and shower13
23.02.2023Consultation: New bathroom, 5.9 sqm with bathtub48
18.03.2021Tiled shower floor - sooner or later trouble due to silicone joint?76
29.10.2021Bathroom planning - Is the splash guard wall of the walk-in shower long enough?14
05.01.2023Bathroom layout 8.7 sqm, with shower and bathtub16
04.05.2024Oval design bathtub – can it be moved slightly due to dirt behind it?71
30.04.202513,000 to renew old shower and bathtub?17

Oben