Smarthome Philips Hue and Somfy TaHoma experiences

  • Erstellt am 2021-11-24 10:45:05

Mycraft

2021-12-02 14:14:25
  • #1
You can connect any modern wired motor to a more or less arbitrary actuator. However, I would not wait for the Eltako series 64. These have been announced for a long time like the BER but are still nowhere available.
 

Araknis

2021-12-02 14:29:41
  • #2
At Somfy, I would definitely clarify something like that beforehand. I don't trust that company at all. Why so desperately Somfy, anyway?

Have a look at OPUS GreenNet...
 

tomtom79

2021-12-02 14:36:16
  • #3
Our ceilings

Why be so extremely opposed to Somfy? Our system has been running without failure for 6 years.

And they don't just have roller shutter controls, there are flush-mounted actuators, sockets, sensors, etc.

Of course, a wired system is superior, but the initial investment is more expensive.
 

Araknis

2021-12-02 15:46:36
  • #4
If you stay completely within the Somfy universe, only need shading, and are okay with that, there’s nothing against it. I just see it from the perspective "above," when you have to integrate blinds into other control systems. Then it’s a disaster.
 

Nixwill

2021-12-02 19:56:40
  • #5
By the time my house is built it will probably be 2023, I think they should be available by then :D... For me, it’s specifically about the integration with HomeKit, that sounds somehow very easy to implement with the 64 series. Not desperately, I don’t even know if there is a wired Somfy version, definitely the radio version. I personally don’t have a favorite yet, I just want it to be simple and, ideally, to work with my wishes included :D. I know, it’s a contradiction… OPUS was also recommended to me in another forum, I’m just a bit skeptical because I’ve never heard of it before, but unfortunately that doesn’t mean much…
 

Nixwill

2021-12-02 20:11:58
  • #6
I have to honestly say that I still don’t quite understand why wired is supposed to be so much better. I have been using the experience of specialists in their fields for years: Nuki for front doors, Tado for heating, Hue for lighting, Eve for switches and sensors, and you could probably go on like that. Honestly, I haven’t had a failure in many years, and I just need to get it into my head slowly that there is no 100% fail-safe system. I think it doesn’t matter whether it’s wired or wireless. At some point, you have to replace broken things, that will always be the case.
For what reason should I stubbornly insist on cables in my walls when there are now well-functioning wireless solutions for almost everything? I’ve often heard: “not another bridge” lalala, but honestly, I am planning an electrical cabinet, and whether there are 5 or 10 bridges in there really doesn’t bother me much. Of course, I always think about reliability with new systems (like with Somfy, for example, regarding range), but on the other hand, I’m just a freak who wants to eliminate every risk, even though he knows he won’t manage that anyway, and in the worst case, something has to be replaced —> no big deal. But even here, considering the time, a quickly replaced (wireless) system is actually the easier option, following the motto: unplug away, plug in.
This is not meant to provoke silence; I just wanted to lay out my mental block and of course hope for more arguments and explanations to make myself smarter… I am open to new things and will dig in, but I need to understand the advantages…
 

Similar topics
18.10.2019Wired surveillance cameras - yes or no?20
08.06.2020Which sensors for what? Inspiration76
28.09.2020Burglary Protection: Planning Outdoor Lighting with Sensors22
17.03.2021Basics of wireless smart home solutions69

Oben