The decisive factor is not the square meters, but how the space can be used. The question is also how your kitchen should eventually look - the wider version of your neighbor could be quite unergonomic/ with many walking paths. In your narrower version, a two-row variant with better spacing can be implemented; whether an island still has space (if you absolutely want one) is questionable. So you should definitely think about how the kitchen should eventually look.
In the planning, I would also seriously consider whether you really need two doors right next to each other; at the moment, you are not saving any walking distance but are taking away storage space. Possibly, instead of the kitchen door, you could plan work surfaces/ tall cabinets there or at least move the kitchen door much closer to the front door (then possibly an L-shaped layout on the bottom and left walls of the plan, tall cabinets on the wall towards the hallway - this also saves a dead corner or a more expensive corner cabinet).