Gable risk

Hello,

we are currently planning the new construction of a detached house with a gable roof. We really like the version with the so-called shield gable (example picture see attachment), but our architect said that this represents a significant structural risk and also brings many other disadvantages:

- As an internal roof, the likelihood of water ingress is considerable
- Regular maintenance is required
- More expensive to manufacture (approx. 1500 EUR for a detached house with 150 m² living space)

In the new development areas in Münsterland, it feels like every third house has a shield gable. I now wonder: Are the builders all so risk-friendly, or is our architect exaggerating?

Thanks for your opinions and experiences.

Best regards
Kassiopeia

I think you have to see it relatively. Relatively, the risk is probably higher, but if done and maintained properly, it is probably justifiable. Your architect is fulfilling his duty to provide information.

By the way, I like that too ...