Contract unclear: humus earth collectors

  • Erstellt am 2015-05-14 00:07:27

michaelbln

2015-05-14 00:07:27
  • #1
Hello,
our construction is set to begin in a month, we will be building with a general contractor (GU).
How does the following situation look:

According to the performance construction description, the houses of our GU have an air heat pump.

During the earthworks for the basement slab, the reapplication of the topsoil is clearly excluded (OK, as it is not further relevant for the house itself).

In an additional agreement, a brine heat pump was agreed upon at the offered fixed price with the following addition: "Energy generation via ground collectors installed in the soil." This means there is no exclusion for the topsoil here, and during the conversation before signing the contract, it was mentioned on inquiry that all earthworks are included for the ground collector. The reapplication of the topsoil stored on the property for 400 sqm is now supposed to cost a flat additional 1500€.

Do we have to pay this?
Thanks

Greetings from Berlin,
Michael
 

Bauexperte

2015-05-14 00:19:54
  • #2
Good evening Michael,


I’m afraid so, if the additional agreement regarding the ground source heat pump service does not explicitly include the earthworks.

It does not apply that what is not excluded in writing has been purchased, but rather that what has been confirmed in writing definitely belongs to the owed service ;)

Best regards from the Rhineland
 

Voki1

2015-05-14 09:20:05
  • #3
One should not make it that simple. I assume that these works were not explicitly mentioned in the contract. However, the question is how a reasonably thinking third party would be allowed to understand this contract. If the contract is also otherwise structured in such a way that service components are not broken down into their individual tasks, but rather only the desired result is summarized, then this provision could possibly be interpreted to mean that certainly neither the shifting of the topsoil nor the laying of the collectors were intended alone, but naturally also the refilling of the excavated field.

So it depends on the entire contract and not on a tiny excerpt of the formulations. ;)
 

Bauexperte

2015-05-14 10:42:39
  • #4
Good morning,


Then I am curious to see what the respective general contractor thinks of your interpretation, or how they shape the relationship between subcontractor and general contractor. It concerns me that the subcontractor did not specify the additional cost for the ZV "energy generation via surface collectors installed in the ground" and has otherwise held back information.


One "could" see it that way, but I lack faith ... although I am also an atheist :D

Rhenish greetings
 

Voki1

2015-05-14 10:50:15
  • #5


I too am rather the wrong person for questions of faith. ;) Unfortunately, one often only learns the full story gradually. It's a bit like ping pong when the "selection" of information by the inquirer is somewhat driven by the desired outcome. The weighting of the facts then sometimes swings intensely back and forth. ;)
 

michaelbln

2015-05-15 07:14:32
  • #6
Thanks in advance, the contractual relationship is structured as follows: There is a contract document based on an offer and a service description. The service description is of course quite detailed, but an earth collector is not mentioned there, only the air heat pump as standard. The offer with house size and floor plans was supplemented accordingly with the above sentence. A price for the earth collector is not listed in the offer but included in the final price.
 

Similar topics
16.06.2011Conclude a construction contract under reservation?10
13.09.2012Feeling pressured into a contract, is that normal?17
29.09.2011Is construction pre-planning without signature / contract legally valid?12
07.03.2014Earthworks are starting, but I need a tip.12
04.07.2016Building without a contract - Concerns?39
10.09.2016Construction financing and contract with the developer24
28.05.2017Plundering the Riester contract - for less need for credit?16
28.08.2017Earthworks: Making the right choice of provider14
16.08.2018Civil engineering works without a contract - normal, experiences?10
29.10.2018Earthworks in the construction performance description17
08.04.2019Earthworks costs in Bavaria15
06.06.2019Completion date in General Contractor Agreement - Wording assistance62
08.09.2020Earthworks costs, hillside house14
09.05.2021Price adjustment clause in the contract with the general contractor18
23.07.2021Earthworks... Dispute with the occupational disability insurance20
27.11.2021Ancillary construction costs for earthworks according to soil report16
10.05.2022Carry out earthworks with equity capital?10
07.02.2025Cost issue for earthworks on a slope22

Oben