Which of the two floor plans is better?

  • Erstellt am 2023-01-26 23:44:28

Charlie90

2023-01-26 23:44:28
  • #1
Hello,

I would like to know which of the two floor plans you prefer.

One floor plan has a straight staircase (small open gallery) and the second has a half-turn staircase; unfortunately, all staircases have advantages and disadvantages.

And whether the hallway might be too large?

 

SoL

2023-01-27 00:09:40
  • #2
Clearly, the hallway is potentially too large. I would choose the option without a study because the option with a study uses space for a room that is not accessible (no door). What does the upper floor look like in this regard? It’s best to start planning from the top.
 

11ant

2023-01-27 01:05:19
  • #3
First of all, "thanks" for the computer crash when viewing the six-and-a-half square meter (!) drawings :-( This initially shows that you are using an unsuitable drawing program. Keep in mind that not only are the gigapixel images difficult for participants to view, but later on, in a 1:1 scale, the masons will only be working with one point three dpi resolution – this "precision" is therefore complete nonsense. I don't want to "criticize" your floor plans in detail yet, because the most significant weak point has already been noted by my predecessor: these are each ground floors, which is the least suitable approach. Stair shapes, by the way, do not only have pros and cons compared to each other, but in any case have a centrally defining influence on the overall floor plan. A straight, single-flight staircase is somewhat the "stick up the a**" of a floor plan. With only a few more ingredients, you can make a floor plan completely unworkable if you put the cart before the horse like that. After you have dealt with the property and can approach the floor plans, it is best to start not with any drawing at all, but with a table. In this, you enter the rooms and then "qualify" them with their approximate floor sizes. Then you assign them to the floors. The "weight" of the areas in the lists "EG" and "OG" should be approximately in the ratio 50:50 ("city villa") or 65:35 ("one-and-a-half storey") to each other. Once you have achieved this balancing, you start with the upper floor, the layout of which you first develop. The ground floor then follows this layout. This rule assumes an entrance on the ground floor; for sloped lots, you have to vary the approach. The strictness of this derivation also depends on the load-bearing walls. If "your" design is largely based on a template, it is helpful in the discussion to name the original model (no link!), and describe the variations (e.g. family with three children or two home offices).
 

WilderSueden

2023-01-27 08:41:47
  • #4
"I wanted to ask which car you like better..." Under what requirements? Leaving out the study room only makes sense if you actually don't need one. Otherwise, it has to go to the upper floor. And if you work from home four days a week, you might want more than the broom closet ;) There is a questionnaire in this forum that you can follow first and then possibly present the new result. With the questionnaire.
 

hanghaus2023

2023-01-27 08:59:45
  • #5
I would first like to see the property. Plan and photos of the surroundings.

So few windows make no sense.
 

hanghaus2023

2023-01-27 09:10:49
  • #6
I have arranged the floor plans a bit more simply for easier viewing.


 

Similar topics
11.12.2015Question about floor plan, especially stairs13
02.05.2016Staircase floor plan design, tread and stringer21
12.07.2016Floor plan question, garage, stairs33
15.08.2016Technical room as small as possible - under the stairs?10
16.02.2017Straight staircase - why?14
06.03.2017Finishing staircase - parquet28
08.08.2019Overlap of one floor with the staircase11
23.11.2019Receive various floor plans for the notary appointment10
13.11.2020Space under the stairs not buildable17
25.07.2021LED strip ascending parallel to the staircase12
20.04.2021Positioning of a single-family house on an elongated north-south plot10
05.05.2021Stairs wrongly concreted, what now? Completion to the upper floor12
25.05.2021Straight staircase for single-family house: Are the dimensions okay?18
01.10.2021Clad open gallery with staircase12
02.02.2022Any ideas for redesigning the staircase?20
23.03.2023LED staircase lighting distances for curved stairs21
09.01.2023Design concrete path with stairs and wall area10
18.02.2023Floor plan - plot for a single-family house, slight slope approx. 175m²67
01.07.2023Layout question: Replace straight staircase with L-shaped staircase31

Oben