Subsequent structural change/costs

  • Erstellt am 2019-11-08 21:02:01

Citrus91

2019-11-08 21:02:01
  • #1
Hello,
we have concluded a consumer construction contract with a house building company. The contract contains the clause that due to ordered measures with the building permit or in the calculation of the statics, (subsequent) additional services may arise.

We exchanged the wooden staircase against a concrete staircase compared to the type house we selected. The seller offered us this change at that time for an additional price of about €200 and it was included in the contract before signing. After the contract was signed, the structural engineer calculated at some point, the building application and the building permit were completed, the house building company now wants to claim additional services due to the statics. The ceiling between the ground floor and the upper floor is to be changed from 18cm to 22cm because of the staircase. This is supposed to cost about €1000. So five times the original €200. Is this lawful? Or where is the limit?

Thank you very much for the answer(s).
 

Tina mit K

2019-11-08 21:13:28
  • #2
I would say the 200 euros were only the additional cost to replace the stairs. We also paid the extra 1000 euros for the structural engineer because we needed a stronger base plate due to the pile foundation.
 

Citrus91

2019-11-08 21:18:36
  • #3


Yes, of course 200€ was the replacement. But it can't be that the whole process actually costs 1200€ afterwards. That amount should be included on the price tag from the beginning. Or not?
 

HilfeHilfe

2019-11-08 21:23:47
  • #4
Nope. The structural engineer is mentioned. Additional cost
 

Tina mit K

2019-11-08 21:36:39
  • #5
But that can happen. Depending on what is in your [Bauleistungsbeschreibung]. Often it says something like "changes to the floor plan can lead to additional costs in the structural engineering" or something of that kind. Of course, you should have been informed that a heavy staircase leads to a changed structural engineering, but really very few sellers do that...
 

Citrus91

2019-11-08 21:43:13
  • #6


Yes, of course, but there has to be a financial cap. It can't be that I buy a house for amount X and then the structural engineer comes and says what still needs to be done and suddenly the price becomes 5 times amount X.

In my opinion, there is a 10% rule for craftsmen's bills. An invoice may deviate from the quote by 10%. There must be such rules in our case as well. There has to be a limit.
 

Similar topics
22.09.2012Who else fell for a contract with a reservation clause? - Search13
08.01.2018Stairs in the hallway, the floor plan is actually already done :o(20
07.03.2015What should be considered when designing stairs / differences in the winding?22
26.06.2015Floor plan question, stairs, window, orientation12
27.08.20152 full floors, passage to garage, utility room under stairs25
15.08.2016Civil engineer contradicts structural engineer27
15.01.2017Which staircase did you take?77
17.10.2017Single-family house approx. 150 sqm floor plan - How to plan the staircase?65
24.09.2018City villa with straight staircase, open modern design, 140m²18
05.08.2020Contract for land purchase - obligation to build within 2.5 years18
15.08.2020Cupboard under the stairs or small storage room11
04.11.2020Terrace roofing 30m2 - Building permit Saxony-Anhalt10
11.02.2021Structural engineer needed for rough assessment of load-bearing capacity25
17.02.202113 sqm larger house 30,000€ additional price35
05.12.2021Cost of structural engineer single-family house23
25.11.2021Floor plan change single-family house 150 m² due to stairs36
01.01.2023Structural engineer according to HOAI or flat rate offer?13
09.08.2023Reopen floor slab for new staircase. Support ceiling in the middle?10

Oben