Problem with construction contract before purchase contract?

  • Erstellt am 2022-01-13 15:30:11

tamer.darweesh

2022-01-13 15:30:11
  • #1
Hello everyone,

A friend and I are planning to jointly purchase a plot of land. The plot currently has a single-family house, which the owner will demolish, and the plot will be divided. The owner has already submitted a preliminary building request, and we will only sign the contract once the building permit is approved.

We are currently also reviewing construction offers for building 2 semi-detached houses. We are building the houses independently of the landowner.

I assume that in our case the two contracts are completely independent. The construction company does not even know who the landowner is.

The real estate agent told me that I have to pay property transfer tax on the construction contract even if the construction contract is signed before or shortly after the purchase contract.

Does the order of the contracts affect the property transfer tax?

The notary also included this statement in the purchase contract:
"The buyer declares that he has not yet signed a construction contract for the development of the contractual plot of land."

Why is it necessary not to sign a construction contract before purchasing the land? Is this legally required?

The bank says they need a construction contract with a fixed price guarantee to avoid financing problems.

Thank you very much and best regards
 

WilderSueden

2022-01-13 15:41:05
  • #2
Are the two contracts related, e.g. the construction company arranged the land or you are obliged to build with a certain company? Then it is a tied transaction and the real estate transfer tax is due on both. If you found the land yourself and freely chose the construction company, then only on the land.

Basically, it is somewhat problematic to sign the construction contract before the land is buildable and in your ownership. The fixed prices are time-limited and if something is delayed, the construction company is allowed to increase the prices. Also, if something goes wrong with the land purchase (someone offers the previous owner more) you still have a construction contract that you have to fulfill or terminate under penalty.


Are you financing the entire amount directly? Then of course the bank also needs a contract. But then you also have to make sure that you can start building quickly, otherwise you incur commitment interest. Alternatively, you can finance only the land variably and later arrange financing for the house and the remaining debt of the land.
 

Benutzer200

2022-01-13 15:43:48
  • #3
That is nonsense to begin with. It can have an effect. The tax office might think that it is a single contractual arrangement. For such an arrangement, signing a construction contract before the purchase contract is an indication. This often happens when you only get the land if you also sign the construction contract with a specified construction company. To avoid waking up any sleeping dogs at the tax office in the first place – this is standard. He doesn’t know what you have already done (unless you tell him). It is not, and no. That is not necessary either. There are so many homeowners building without a fixed price guarantee. For architect-designed buildings, for example, it is not possible otherwise. If the bank is that picky from the start, take another bank. Why don’t you buy the land subject to the condition precedent of a positive preliminary decision? Then all problems are solved and you can calmly examine construction offers.
 

HilfeHilfe

2022-01-14 05:48:36
  • #4
You only sign the construction contract after the property has been purchased. Otherwise, you have a problem. The house bought without the property
 

tamer.darweesh

2022-01-14 08:45:08
  • #5

No, the construction company doesn't even know the landowner or the broker.


I found the plot on the internet. Originally, the owner/broker suggested a certain construction company. But I got a better offer, so I decided to build the house with another company whose name the owner/broker doesn't even know.



For this problem, the construction company proposed to include this clause in the construction contract:
"The contract is only valid after the plot purchase"
Would this be considered a connection to the purchase contract? I thought it was just too general and basically necessary, since you can't build a house without a plot.


Yes, this is financing for the entire project. The banks were not very interested in granting partial financing only for the plot.


Thanks for the hint. I think we will be able to prove that this is not the case. We already have several offers from different construction companies (including the one suggested by the owner/broker, which we did not accept).


OK. I have contacted the notary to clarify this situation. I assume we can then remove this clause without problems.


I am not sure if I understood that correctly. The broker and the architect (on behalf of the landowner) recommend that we only sign the contract once the preliminary building permit is available. That would make clear what we are buying.
 

Benutzer200

2022-01-14 10:54:30
  • #6
Exactly as I wrote it. The purchase contract only becomes valid once the building permit notice is available. If the building permit notice is not positive, the purchase contract becomes void. It is also possible to agree on different prices, depending on the approved possibilities. You will then incur notary costs, but you have the security that you have secured the land. This is routine for professional real estate investors, but not so common in the private sector.
 

Similar topics
20.10.2014Preliminary contract with the general contractor for building a house after purchasing land16
14.12.2017Property acquisition tax notice for land same contract document21
06.12.2016Contract for work before property purchase - real estate acquisition tax?10
24.03.2017Property acquisition tax - Was everything calculated correctly?16
16.01.2017Notary selection - how to proceed?14
12.04.2017Garage price in the purchase contract from the notary is lower18
08.01.2018Finance the purchase of land yourself in advance or wait?17
02.05.2018Right to information from the notary even after purchase?43
07.12.2018Check purchase contract / waiver of pre-emption right is waived27
06.02.2019Purchase contract, is review by a lawyer required?11
24.02.2019Property acquisition tax on a house not yet built - yes/no?13
30.01.2020Tax office questionnaire for the assessment of real estate transfer tax11
07.11.2020Notary contract land inspection: should it be done or not?24
16.01.2021Property purchase - Risk of a "linked transaction"?61
25.02.2021Coupling business or not?21
25.07.2021Semi-detached house: two contracts (landowner and construction company)41
19.07.2021Is the broker contract legal?11
16.02.20254 years after construction, the office also demands land acquisition tax on the house96
15.02.2024Close with a different selling price than discussed with the broker?35
07.09.2024Notarial Purchase Agreement - No Guarantee for Building Land29

Oben