How high will the early repayment penalty be?

  • Erstellt am 2024-05-07 21:57:42

thesit27

2024-05-08 11:26:50
  • #1
Hello everyone,

unfortunately we have the same case...
256K taken out in 2018 at an interest rate of 1.89% for 15 years.
Remaining debt should be about 180€.

Can someone explain to me again why one shouldn't pay a prepayment penalty? Because interest rates are so high at the moment?
I don't quite understand...
But of course I would be very happy!

Thank you very much!
 

nordanney

2024-05-08 11:37:39
  • #2
Gladly. The bank gets the money back from you at time X. At this point, the bank reinvests the money with the same term (simplified) as your loan still runs (in reality, the exact cash flows are modeled, prepayment options are considered exercised, and calculation is done up to the termination option according to section 489 of the German Civil Code - with a 30-year fixed interest rate, this means not for e.g. another 25 years. Details would go too far here.) Then, it is compared - what the bank earns from the loan and what it earns from reinvestment in securities (mainly mortgage bonds). If the reinvestment rate is higher, nothing is owed and vice versa. That was the simplified explanation.
 

thesit27

2024-05-08 13:56:30
  • #3


Many thanks for the kind reply!!! So with our interest rate of 1.89%, we are very likely to be lucky and get out of the contract without a prepayment penalty if we sell the property?
That would of course be a relief. We had expected at least 20k.
 

Zaba123

2024-05-08 14:02:54
  • #4
Good fresh start! The feedback has been clearly positive. I mean, after all, nothing prevents the bank from applying the clause for the prepayment penalty even if the bank has not suffered any damage, unless the prepayment penalty in the contract is directly related to an interest loss, which does not occur in the current interest environment with a new investment.
 

thesit27

2024-05-08 14:22:28
  • #5

Thanks for the kind encouragement!!!

Still, I wouldn’t understand the bank; they could first demand a nice compensation from me and then "reinvest" the money at better conditions, or am I missing something?
 

Zaba123

2024-05-08 14:39:14
  • #6


Two aspects could apply here: the economic and/or the legal.

1. If the clause regarding early repayment compensation in your loan agreement (even contained in the word itself) specifically refers to the word “damage,” the bank would have to prove in case of a dispute that it suffered damage in the current interest rate environment. With the amount and your interest rate, this is rather impossible.

2. They can better/ newly “invest” the reserved amount.

In combination, the bank simply comes out “better” if you push for it without additional claims.
 

Similar topics
16.06.2011Conclude a construction contract under reservation?10
13.09.2012Feeling pressured into a contract, is that normal?17
29.09.2011Is construction pre-planning without signature / contract legally valid?12
22.09.2012Who else fell for a contract with a reservation clause? - Search13
30.04.2013Loan with an interest rate of 2.51% - Tips for financing22
02.12.2017Prepayment penalty36
16.07.2014What interest rate is realistic?20
24.10.2014Repay savings or save? + Secure interest rate47
16.05.2015Contract unclear: humus earth collectors10
23.08.2015Construction financing with a fixed-term contract13
14.03.2016Financing completed - is the interest rate good?23
01.05.2016Process of property purchase/financing11
04.07.2016Building without a contract - Concerns?39
29.05.2016Conditions for Riester home savings contract - What interest rate?16
16.01.2018Construction financing - is it possible to reduce the interest rate?30
02.11.2018Is the bad weather clause applicable as an excuse for the general contractor?10
18.12.2019Construction financing - Influence of private retirement provision on interest rate35
30.04.2020KfW153 loan immediate repayment - prepayment penalty?24
09.05.2021Price adjustment clause in the contract with the general contractor18
17.04.2025Prepayment Penalty for Loans vs. Current Interest Earnings112

Oben