First of all, thank you for your extensive answers! We also believe that this is simply the usual price gouging for additional work.
In the meantime, we have even coordinated briefly with our new neighbors; for them, the location of the pump would be absolutely irrelevant since their bedroom faces the other side.
Now our question would be whether the location of the pump is not legally allowed there "because of this sound radius" or whether these are more recommendations and can be dismissed.
In the latter case, we would leave the pump where it costs us nothing and just deal with it.