When making an old house habitable, we are simply considering using OSB boards as flooring and leaving the existing old carpet underneath; basically as insulation.
Has anyone done this before?
You might want to explain "making habitable" once, you could also dye the old carpet.......
Honestly......an old carpet harbors things that you definitely shouldn’t preserve like that.
The carpet must come out, and until you have really carefully installed an OSB floor, you have to put in real effort, especially at the joints and transitions.
Then you better buy very cheap laminate or something similar somewhere on clearance, which is also easy to install. Considering the carpet as insulation is already adventurous.
Affordable and natural product.
Cheap yes in terms of price per square meter, but including additional work more expensive than cheap laminate. And... eco-OSB (just check WHAT is actually in it!) and underneath a musty carpet, calling that natural is out of the question. Your carpet is guaranteed 101% not natural.