Building Code vs. VOB/B - Security Deposit?

  • Erstellt am 2019-12-31 18:38:07

Donludo

2019-12-31 18:38:07
  • #1
We have a contract offer that clearly refers to VOB/B.

Does the new Construction Law [Baugesetzbuch Baurecht] then not apply – in particular the max. 90% advance invoice issuance and the 5% retention of security?
There is nothing about this in the payment schedule...

Thank you
 

Vicky Pedia

2020-01-03 11:59:39
  • #2
Hello Donludo,
The Building Code always applies in general. If a contract is agreed upon according to VOB, then VOB always takes precedence (higher overrides lower). Only in cases where VOB does not provide regulations for certain matters does the Building Code apply.
The right to payment and retention is also regulated in the VOB. It may also be the case that the contractor has a performance bond and/or warranty bond, in which case he is entitled to 100% payment.
But I believe you mean something completely different. The mentioned payment plan primarily regulates the due dates of the payments. It is generally individually negotiable but is subject to the provisions of the Real Estate Agent and Developer Ordinance.
Obviously, you want to build with a developer. He certainly has presented a payment plan in 7-9 steps. It usually starts at the beginning of construction and ends with the acceptance, whereby defects and remaining services are to be deducted here.
The payment plan contains percentages of the total construction sum and are due in full (exception last installment). Any additions are usually invoiced after completion. There are dozens of articles on this topic on Dr. Google.
 

Otus11

2020-01-03 13:42:51
  • #3

No. The VOB/B itself is not a law but general contractual conditions. It must also be effectively incorporated – especially towards consumers.
A VOB/B contract with consumers has therefore meant since 2018: Construction Code + VOB/B.
This also ensures consumer protection (which was previously guaranteed by the Federal Court of Justice jurisprudence; the ruling at the time: No VOB/B against consumers, but interpretation in the sense of the Construction Code contract law).

If a construction contract within the meaning of § 650 a Construction Code is present, then since 01.01.2018, in addition to the regulations on the contract for work, §§ 650 b – 650 h Construction Code apply additionally.
According to § 650 n Construction Code, deviations to the detriment of consumers from the provisions serving consumer protection of the §§ 650 h – 650 k Construction Code and § 650 n Construction Code are not permitted.

Section 650 m para. 1 Construction Code (= total amount of installment payments may not exceed 90 percent of the agreed total remuneration including supplements) is thus not covered, i.e. negotiable. Other divergent individual arrangements are therefore possible.


Broker and Developer Ordinance only applies if it is a developer contract (work + land) – which is not clearly evident here.
 

Vicky Pedia

2020-01-03 15:04:14
  • #4
Thanks to @Otuss11. I learned something again there. And how does your contribution now help the questioner?
 

Hausbaer

2021-10-01 15:06:43
  • #5
Do I understand correctly that the VOB/B conditions are significantly better from a consumer protection perspective, regarding the security retention? In the VOB/B, the retention may be kept until the end of the warranty period, but in the Baugesetzbuch only until acceptance.
 

Similar topics
19.02.2015Development costs §127 Building Code12
22.09.2015Building Code - Developer Contract - Postponement of Contractual Handover Date14
04.07.2016Building without a contract - Concerns?39
06.07.2016Security retention of craftsman invoices15
05.10.2016Apartment sale through an agent - what to pay attention to?27
15.10.2016VOB / Advantages/Disadvantages from the perspective of clients and contractors11
04.05.2021Broker for owners - benefits / advantages?153
02.10.2018Negotiation strategy with the agent and the seller40
24.04.2020How do brokers negotiate the purchase price?43
15.10.2019Questions on the interpretation of § 34 Building Code59
14.04.2020Security deposit according to §650 of the Building Code20
02.02.2020Payment plan (Broker and Developer Regulation) and Developer's payment plan10
06.05.2020Liberation § 31 Building Code: Roof pitch, roof shape, roof structures15
11.11.2020Cancellation of a contract with a plumbing company24
13.01.2021Broker fraud or tax evasion?63
10.04.2021Delays with the general contractor, no deadline set according to § 650 Building Code65
21.08.2021§34 Building Code: Building Window and Garage21
29.12.2022Special right of termination according to § 489 Building Code - Refunds15
27.01.2024House purchase through agent, now contract terminated18

Oben