What is set in stone in the building permit application?

  • Erstellt am 2018-12-13 20:33:20

Christian K.

2018-12-13 20:33:20
  • #1
Hello everyone,

we are interested in what aspects of the draft become "set in stone" in the building application.

Background:
We had a draft drawn up by an architect. The draft was then transferred by a building planning office and from that the building application was created. The problem is that some details no longer fit. The planning office says that this is not relevant for the building application and that these details could be considered during construction. We just have to stay within the specifications of the development plan. In other words, if we change the floor heights, that is okay as long as the total height remains the same or does not exceed the permissible total height. The windows are not exactly aligned in the building application, but that would not be a problem either. If they are offset by a few centimeters, or made larger, that fits. Just not turning a 1m window into a 3m window.

So how is it now? Should we be meticulous about the details in the building application, or is the draft in the building application really rough, as long as we adhere to the development plan?

We would be very happy about your assessment :-)

Thank you, CK
 

hemali2003

2018-12-13 21:05:12
  • #2
I would be picky about that! We only submitted the building application once everything fit. Why change it afterwards? It doesn't make any sense – there must be a plan anyway that shows everything exactly as it should be executed.

And if the building application and execution planning differ, mistakes are bound to happen!
 

Mottenhausen

2018-12-13 21:07:33
  • #3
I would try to incorporate all changes at once.

1. There will certainly still be changes during execution anyway, and if later someone really takes a closer look it’s better if there aren’t 1000 differences between the building application and reality. There are also unpleasant neighbors who are just waiting for such a template.

2. There is a risk that afterwards it will be said: "If you had told us that earlier, we can’t change it now, the material has already been ordered, the structural calculations have already been done, etc. or we can gladly change it, but that now costs money.

PS. I know you don’t feel comfortable... overturning the finished planning again, but that simply doesn’t help and the builder planner already gets enough money for it, so please let him make the window the way it’s supposed to be!
 

nordanney

2018-12-13 23:32:45
  • #4
The answer to your question is a clear yes and no. If a window were to shift a few centimeters, no one would actually care. A pragmatic approach.

However, if you change essential things like the floor height, I would personally ALWAYS fill out the building application with the correct data and not start building on a whim. Otherwise, you wouldn’t need to submit a plan at all if you stay within the specifications of the development plan anyway ;-)
 

Escroda

2018-12-14 07:37:36
  • #5
If you only make a building notification according to §64 HBO, you can IMHO dispense with the notification of all changes conforming to the development plan. Although this is not entirely correct, since the designer is responsible for compliance with all building regulations and the authorities do not have to check or approve anything, it is quite justifiable. In the building permit procedure according to §65 HBO, I agree with the opinions of the previous speakers.
 

ypg

2018-12-14 10:52:20
  • #6


That’s how it was explained to us as well.
In our case, a window was misplaced. It was then corrected on the plans for the building application with a ballpoint pen as a freehand drawing. It was clear what was meant.
 

Similar topics
17.12.2014Building application "deferred". What does that mean?19
26.06.2015Floor plan question, stairs, window, orientation12
30.10.2015Can the building application be submitted this year?14
22.01.2016Kitchen planning with island and floor-to-ceiling windows12
01.02.2017Building application is becoming increasingly complicated!20
19.05.2018Floor plan of new single-family house: Are window/door/interior wall size/arrangement okay?20
14.10.2018Building application - delay due to neighbor's lawsuit - experiences?21
18.01.2019Single-family house design - approx. 160-170 sqm / Innovative pitched roof71
26.02.2019Submit a building application before the land is paid for?11
14.01.2020Please provide tips for designing the ground floor plan33
03.02.2020Floor area ratio / plot ratio in the development plan of 196811
02.06.2020Draft floor plan EG/OG as well as L-canopy - tips17
30.07.2020First draft from the architect - optimization28
05.08.2020Building a garden shed... Is a building permit necessary? Detours?17
20.10.2020NRW: Exemption procedure with minor deviation from the development plan18
31.05.2021Draft for extension/conversion of single-family house to ZFS17
10.07.2022Bathroom planning 14m², new build, square, two windows70
10.03.2023Preliminary building approval positive, building application criticized position29
17.07.2023Municipal development plan insufficiently executed, what applies?32

Oben