Structural engineer: 2x 8mm reinforcement or 1x 16mm

  • Erstellt am 2017-03-29 09:53:29

pixelprof

2017-03-29 09:53:29
  • #1
How does the tensile strength of reinforced concrete (e.g., in horizontal beams) behave when I use 2 x 8mm reinforcement bars compared to 1 x 16mm? Or 2 x 6mm compared to 1 x 12mm? (Assuming identical components and the same steel quality.)
 

ypg

2017-03-29 09:55:58
  • #2
Wrong forum? Here are home builders :)

Regards, Yvonne
 

andimann

2017-03-29 10:48:27
  • #3
Hi,



Simply put:
just calculate the cross-sectional areas, that should answer your question:

Cross-section of the 8mm reinforcement: 50 mm^2 (4*4*pi)
Cross-section of the 16mm reinforcement: 200 mm^2 (8*8*pi)

The tensile strength of reinforced concrete is largely determined by the reinforcement. Replacing one 16mm bar with two 8mm bars is therefore not feasible; you would rather need 4 8mm bars.

In reality, it is probably not that simple, as there will be other influencing factors, such as the distribution and position of the reinforcement.

Regards,

Andreas
 

Similar topics
15.08.2016Floor slab removed afterward, reinforcement visible22
11.10.2016Reinforcement / Armature visible31
27.07.2019Cost comparison: reinforced concrete + ETICS vs. brick or wall + ETICS22
17.08.2019Base plate - Reinforcement steel is sticking out12
28.10.2019Base plate - reinforcement visible from the side15

Oben