Roof insulation Styrofoam or Isover

  • Erstellt am 2022-08-24 11:43:04

Fahrenheit

2022-08-24 11:43:04
  • #1
Just a quick question: I intend to retrofit insulation on the inside of my roof in the uninsulated area. I could use mineral wool (Isover) or Styrofoam. Which is more sensible? And how do the application thicknesses compare? I mean, what is the thickness ratio for the same insulation value? Isover is 16cm thick (0.032W). How thick do I need to make the Styrofoam to achieve the same value? I think Styrofoam is easier to work with? Thanks in advance.............................................
 

SaniererNRW123

2022-08-24 12:04:13
  • #2
Roof or top floor ceiling? Purpose of the insulation? Attic conversion? Check out ubakus on Gurgel. There you can calculate everything yourself. Otherwise, the question remains whether you have any knowledge about the correct construction of insulation? By the way, mineral wool is much easier to work with. And there are other insulation materials that, for example, have significantly better insulation performance. It all depends on your very specific requirements. See my first question.
 

Fahrenheit

2022-08-26 00:21:17
  • #3
Thank you for asking.
Roof - not ceiling. House with a gabled roof is developed at the top. Upper floor to attic is insulated.
The attic to the roof is only boarded, then roofing felt, then slate covering.
Inside, I still have space between the rafters to add additional insulation.
It worked well for years, now due to the new energy discussion I thought if I additionally insulate the attic, which is currently not insulated on the outside, it might still bring some benefits.
I was already at the hardware store today. Styrofoam is more expensive with similar insulation value. It also burns.
So I will take mineral wool, which can also be cut well.
Thanks for the tip (mineral wool), I thought that was only for facades. It is probably more dimensionally stable, so it fits well between the rafters.
I will research price and insulation value.
As mentioned above, for years one hardly thought about it, now due to the price situation one starts to recalculate.
My oil cost 0.75 last year, this year 1.52.---- You really grit your teeth.
My wish for everyone: Hopefully the price for gas will also go down again. (But I hardly believe that..........................)
 

SaniererNRW123

2022-08-26 08:02:08
  • #4
If you don't need the attic otherwise, just lay mineral wool in two layers on the floor and that's it. That would be an alternative.
 

Fahrenheit

2022-08-26 11:12:16
  • #5
Thanks for the tip, but I use the floor as a storage room, so the mineral wool will probably get damaged there. The space between the rafters is available, which is why I think I can better fit the additional insulation there. Mineral wool is by the way more expensive according to my research. Ok for the facade, but with rafter insulation, precision and fit are not that important. As part of the insulation considerations, I had also thought about the facade, but after recalculating and the amortization calculations, I’d rather burn my money in Bermuda. Also, when reading through the discussions here in the forum, I notice that with a (also industry-promoted!) hype, exact recalculations get lost. The important thing is that new investments are made, no matter how the calculations turn out. Some people think they are participating and saving the environment and do not inform themselves about what is happening in the rest of the world. From a human perspective, that’s very positive - but? With best wishes for more sun on the roofs of our photovoltaic and heat pump experts.
 

QQSTSolar

2022-08-26 21:07:40
  • #6
I insulated my rafter space with Styrofoam. I am very satisfied with it.

This is because I absolutely hate mineral wool. I cannot tolerate those flaky little hairs and the itching.
Therefore, I did not use it for that purpose. I only used it for the ceiling between floors, but there it lies between the ceiling without contact.

However, I did not use hardware store Styrofoam, but special Styrofoam for the rafter space from Schwenk. It was slotted, so it could be bent slightly and thus fitted very precisely. With tongue and groove. So it was very easy and quick to work with. I installed a total of 15 cm + drywall. Even in the height of summer it remains comfortable in the upper floor. And nice and warm in winter. So I can only recommend it.
 

Similar topics
19.11.2013Walls made of Styrodur or Styrofoam?10
11.02.2020Poroton T9 unfilled or Poroton T8 mineral wool?21
23.07.2015Use the attic in the new city villa21
27.09.2015Insulation with wood fiber vs. mineral wool11
18.11.2016Polystyrene or mineral wool in winter11
27.03.201724 cm Ytong + insulation or 36.5 cm Ytong63
10.07.2018Does the structural builder have to paint the transition between styrofoam and brick wall black?12
10.02.2019Look for a nice solution for the attic - lighting20
09.03.2020Attic with gable roof 22 degrees roof pitch31
25.03.2020Insulation of the attic as living space15
12.04.2020Isolated drywall chamber for controlled residential ventilation in the attic26
12.08.2020Attic Height - How much storage space is it really?22
07.10.2021Construct attic floor24
29.10.2021Should the ceiling under the attic be insulated?10
22.07.2022Insulation for the top floor ceiling - which material?14
02.10.2022Is insulating the exterior wall sensible or not?20
30.11.2022Shelf for attic - sloping roof without knee wall35
14.12.2022Insulate cold roof attic for office23
17.07.2023Plaster facade WDVS mineral wool brown stains12
31.05.2023Ring beam - Insulation for 5cm U-shaped shell10

Oben