Ring beam and wooden beam ceiling in hip roof - optimal?

  • Erstellt am 2019-02-02 20:31:04

ufr123

2019-02-02 20:31:04
  • #1
Hello everyone,

our current plan for a two-story house with a hipped roof ("Toscanahaus") provides the following roof construction: The top floor ceiling is designed as a wooden beam ceiling. The roof beams rest on a ring beam. Construction otherwise solid brick.

Now two general contractors have told us that this construction method is significantly too expensive because of the ring beam and that a solid concrete ceiling, on which the roof beams rest, would be the technically and economically more advantageous variant. In addition, the summer heat protection would be better due to the concrete ceiling. However, this would make the house higher than in our previous plan, which we actually like quite well.

What do you think? Is a design with a concrete ceiling really the more advantageous variant?

Thank you very much for your assessments, ufr
 

Nordlys

2019-02-02 23:22:46
  • #2
No. Nonsense. Ring beam and insulated wooden ceiling at the top are cheaper. How do they come up with that? Thermal insulation is also not a problem at all.
 

dhd82

2019-02-03 09:47:13
  • #3
Hello,

I have to agree with Nordlys, normally the concrete ceiling is significantly more expensive (but also higher quality). If your general contractor can now offer the concrete ceiling even cheaper, then I would have the execution documented in the contract / construction service description in writing and enjoy the concrete ceiling. We are also currently building and only have a wooden ceiling with drywall in the upper floor to the attic. If I were to build again, then never again with a wooden ceiling, it has no advantages except for the price.
 

Aliban2014

2019-02-03 11:07:14
  • #4
Concrete ceilings are generally more expensive (material proportion > labor proportion), the wooden beam ceiling should generally be somewhat cheaper (labor proportion > material proportion). Therefore, I find the statements unusual.

What else comes to mind:

Concrete ceiling:
- As far as I know, no ring beam necessary, which means the windows can be higher if the lintel reinforcement is integrated statically into the ceiling, so an advantage
- Insulation in my opinion only possible "above" the concrete ceiling, meaning you lose about 20 cm of height at the top of the attic and the 20 cm concrete ceiling is initially "senselessly" heated, so both rather disadvantages in my opinion
- "No" movement relative to the walls, so no cracks as with wooden beam ceilings, so an advantage
- Easier spot planning and installation because the spacing of the wooden beams does not have to be considered

Wooden beam ceiling:
- Opposite of above, ring beam necessary, so windows become lower if the ring beam is not recessed. If it is recessed somewhat, then it can look strange from the outside because the window then "sinks into the roof." If a roof box is added, it definitely looks odd. Similarly high windows as with a concrete ceiling could only be achieved through higher room height and a suspended ceiling in my opinion. So rather a disadvantage. If the windows on the upper floor are to be exactly as high as on the ground floor, the room height on the upper floor must be much higher than on the ground floor because the ring beam requires height.
- Insulation is usually done between the rafters (e.g. floor area divided into 92% insulation 8% wooden beams, thus 8% "heat loss"). Still, in my opinion rather an advantage.
- Wood moves, so over time cracks usually appear at the transitions to the walls if you use rough plaster inside. Probably not a problem with wallpaper. Clearly a disadvantage if you use rough plaster. Maybe can be mitigated if you do longitudinal battens + OSB + drywall instead of just cross battens + drywall as ceiling cladding.
- More tricky spot planning and installation because the spacing of the wooden beams must be considered

Conclusion:
As often with house construction, the choice of ceiling in my opinion is a matter of taste.

Wooden beam ceiling requires more working time in my opinion, so they probably "want" to finish it quickly and not work forever on the wooden beam ceiling and offer it "on paper" cheaper.
 

ufr123

2019-02-03 16:39:26
  • #5
Thank you very much in advance for the answers, that helps us in the decision-making process!



Can you briefly say why you would no longer build with a wooden ceiling? Thanks!
 

dhd82

2019-02-03 22:16:56
  • #6
For a concrete ceiling, you do not need a vapor barrier. The application is a task that must be carried out very thoroughly, otherwise you can have problems with moisture. I meticulously searched our ceiling for leaks after applying the vapor barrier and did find some, and now hope that I have not overlooked anything. It is also significantly easier to attach something to a concrete ceiling than to a ribbed ceiling (not in terms of the necessary force, which is of course much higher for concrete, but in terms of technical execution). You certainly do not live differently in a house with a concrete ceiling between the upper floor and the attic than with a wooden ceiling (unless you convert the attic, then the aspect of sound insulation is added), but with a concrete ceiling you have a construction that is less prone to errors and with which you are more flexible in attaching objects to the ceiling.
 

Similar topics
10.07.2011Wall construction and insulation for Kfw 70 house, okay?19
08.11.2012Insulation in the 70s compared to today, modern insulation, heating costs26
21.08.2014Insulation on upper floor concrete ceiling / roof by own work - vapor barrier?10
27.05.2015Huge problem with condensation on the window34
23.01.2015Single-storey house + attic for 2 persons14
12.08.2015Is insulation worth it beyond the new construction standard?34
07.09.2017Floor slab: Concrete or wooden beam ceiling - Advantages and disadvantages!?20
09.02.2016Wood beam ceiling vs. concrete ceiling16
16.09.2016Upper floor window lintel and ring beam19
29.12.2020Y-Tong vs Concrete without extra insulation in practice (heating costs)38
09.06.2019Cladding after moving in and construction method?12
05.01.2020Window - Installation / Insulation / Sealing / Execution16
07.07.2020Technical room in the attic, problems with soundproofing?36
16.01.2023Full rafter insulation roof or insulation on concrete slab40
15.12.2020Insulate concrete ceiling upper floor69
28.08.2021summer thermal protection - reduction of windows?22
05.03.2022Additional insulation for the ceiling of the upper floor with a warm attic: useful/necessary?10
24.03.2023Work on basement ceiling insulation with stone wool48
20.02.2023Building defect cold bridge at the ring beam?12
31.05.2023Ring beam - Insulation for 5cm U-shaped shell10

Oben