Polystyrene or mineral wool in winter

  • Erstellt am 2016-11-17 14:47:57

deichwacht

2016-11-17 14:47:57
  • #1
We are currently constructing a KfW40 new building using solid construction methods. The following is planned for the exterior walls: on the inside aerated concrete, then 160mm insulation (WLG 032), an air layer, and finally clinker bricks. Our contractor typically uses mineral wool as insulation. Since our house is being built over the winter, the contractor recommended using polystyrene with the same characteristics (160mm, WLG032) instead to avoid moisture problems during the construction phase. Of course, mineral wool is never installed in the rain and is always covered with tarps, but here in the North, the wind can sometimes tear off a tarp over the weekend, and then the mineral wool would get wet. The argument basically seems plausible to me, but ultimately the decision should be ours. In terms of price, the quality would be comparable. However, I would like to hear your assessment.

Pros of mineral wool:
- Does not burn
- Easier to dispose of
- Better heat protection in summer due to more mass (also relevant with our wall structure?)
- Better sound insulation (also relevant with our wall structure? Rather quiet area...)

Pros of polystyrene:
- Insensitive to moisture, resulting in fewer problems and possibly faster construction

Have I overlooked anything? How would you decide?
 

Knallkörper

2016-11-17 14:59:47
  • #2
The mineral wool must withstand water. It can always become damp, even later, because the dew point is on the inside of the bricks.
 

Legurit

2016-11-17 15:02:59
  • #3
It will probably be core insulation - hydrophobized. I would stick with mineral wool. If it gets damaged, the contractor has to replace it. Mineral wool isn't that sensitive anyway.
 

andimann

2016-11-17 15:17:09
  • #4
Mineral wool is also significantly more expensive and much more difficult to process. You simply glue polystyrene to the wall, wool is doweled. The suggestion might come from that... If the general contractor really finds processing mineral wool too complicated in winter, that doesn't reflect well on him... Has he ever built a house before or is yours the first...? ;)

Best regards,

Andreas
 

Knallkörper

2016-11-17 15:22:51
  • #5
The mineral wool is only pushed onto the masonry anchors in clinker construction. I also suspect that the contractor wants to save money.
 

andimann

2016-11-17 15:49:13
  • #6
@ Firecrackers:
Is it really just placed on the wires and done? And it holds? Learned something new today...
Then the processing probably won't be much different.
It would still need to be checked whether the material is more expensive.

Best regards,

Andreas
 

Similar topics
06.03.2018Klinker or plaster? Durability / appearance?19
07.03.2014Klinker or Riemchen !!!28
30.01.2015New building exterior facade clinker/plaster12
09.03.2015Received an offer from a builder: Cost of shell construction - experiences?26
11.02.2020Poroton T9 unfilled or Poroton T8 mineral wool?21
14.11.2016Expansion joint in clinker, yes or no21
25.08.2015Clinker for bungalow13
27.09.2015Insulation with wood fiber vs. mineral wool11
19.06.2016Insulation reveal window WDVS and clinker plus transition12
17.01.2018Is clinker recommended after construction when done by oneself?14
21.01.2018Clinker or plaster facade - What cost differences?10
10.02.2018Klinker veneer cost per sqm - surcharge justified?17
01.11.2020Single-family house 172 sqm, questions about the layout, roof structure, and brickwork90
13.07.2018Insulation of a detached semi-detached house - experiences?15
10.08.2019KFW 40 plus / Energy-efficient building with clinker?13
25.09.2019Perlite-filled bricks (polystyrene, pesticides)10
07.01.2021Looking for clinker in red, brown, orange - should not be too dark23
14.02.2021Wall structure 36.5 Poroton T8 including clinker32
04.08.2022Gray-white clinker, only ceramic?49
17.07.2023Plaster facade WDVS mineral wool brown stains12

Oben