Damages caused by screed work. Who is liable? How to proceed?

  • Erstellt am 2021-02-19 22:14:19

Bautitus

2021-02-19 22:14:19
  • #1
Hello dear forum users,

we are building a house with an architect. Recently, screeding work was carried out at our place. During this, the shell construction, which was supposed to remain visible, was heavily soiled and damaged in several places.

In my opinion, this constitutes a defect because the other trade was not sufficiently protected. However, I wonder how I should proceed to achieve defect remediation.

The screeding company does not want to take any action because, in their opinion, it is "shell construction" and nothing could have been done about it. According to the opinion of other companies that were present, what they did was a big mess. From their reports, I have learned that normally it goes differently. In particular, the hoses are secured with straps to control vibrations/shocks and thus minimize the likelihood of such damage. However, I could not find any DIN standard that would require this.

Is it possible to hold the architect somehow liable, since ultimately a defect-free object will not be handed over? He also did not supervise how the work was carried out. He is completely abandoning us on this matter as well. Does he have no obligations? ([wurde für alle Leistungsphasen beauftragt])

I would be very grateful for any tips.
 

Nordlys

2021-02-19 22:19:16
  • #2
I can hardly imagine a visible raw construction wall, but if that is the plan, A. has to deliver it that way. His problem. You are his client, he deals with the craftsmen, he receives their invoices, he approves them. Or insists on corrections.
 

HilfeHilfe

2021-02-20 06:53:56
  • #3
Photos? Is a shell wall not plastered...?
 

parcus

2021-02-20 11:52:19
  • #4
Did the screed company know through the site manager that it was exposed masonry?
Which can be proven by the item in the tender or later in the order regarding the masking of the walls.

If nothing exists, the screed company can possibly prove that masking was not part of the contract.

What the craftsmen say about a shell construction, .... sorry, at most it’s about broom clean.

Apart from whether airtightness is given at all without plaster on masonry
and whether this is also provided for as such in the thermal insulation certificate.
 

icandoit

2021-02-20 12:31:50
  • #5
Pictures?

Defect?

Your architect is funny. It is his job to hand over your house free of defects.
 

Alessandro

2021-02-24 08:59:41
  • #6
By the way, a DIN is not a regulation but a recommendation. So you don't need to come with such things at all.
 

Similar topics
18.02.2011Architect totally messed up - experiences?17
10.04.2015Cost estimate architect single-family house. Your assessment44
11.09.2015Building a garage on the boundary is not possible according to the architect.11
10.11.2017House plan by architect 2 floors with basement18
09.12.2017Renovation with architect: Suggestions for house floor plan desired21
24.01.2020Drainage in front of garage door is missing / correct it? Defect?15
10.10.2019Single-family house by architect 150m² improvement suggestions and ideas wanted75
31.03.2020Massive house provider or architect in Corona times19
03.09.2020Modern single-family house with architect in southern Germany25
10.11.2020The architect is wrong with the estimates. And now?29
07.02.2021Single-family house, two floor plan variants from the architect39
18.02.2022Floor plan offer from the architect - your opinion11
27.05.2022Architect - Flat-rate offer instead of HOAI for single-family house12
15.12.2022Planning guest WC in new construction - How big should it be? (DIN?)107
27.12.2022Door DIN left or right – are both possible?17
30.08.2024Renovation or demolition and new construction - decision support from the architect?25

Oben