Building with different stones than in approval planning and structural analysis

  • Erstellt am 2021-03-25 08:43:35

RomanRot

2021-03-25 08:43:35
  • #1
Hi, I have the following question: we originally planned to build our new house with T9 Poroton bricks 36.5cm, this would also be approved and the static and thermal insulation calculations would be created accordingly. Now we have received the suggestion to build the house with aerated concrete blocks ytong. Now my question is, would the static and thermal insulation calculations have to be redone here?
 

face26

2021-03-25 08:51:52
  • #2
Hi,

yes.
 

hampshire

2021-03-25 11:51:04
  • #3
The stones are obviously relevant for structural stability and thermal insulation. Other properties = new calculation.
 

icandoit

2021-03-25 15:56:42
  • #4
If the wall thickness, strength class, and thermal conductivity coefficient are the same or better, in my opinion it should be possible without structural analysis or a new thermal protection calculation.

As a rule, the documents state "or equivalent".
 

11ant

2021-03-25 17:51:04
  • #5

Who even makes such a suggestion – some pub talker who enjoys unsettling colleagues with his baker’s dozen knowledge during lunch breaks?
There is no philosopher’s stone and no devil’s stone. Absolutely speaking, there is no stone with properties that one must warn against (or consider oneself lucky to have found Columbus’s egg). However, relatively speaking, every stone is “bad” with which the builder has little (or less) experience. Details in other properties lead to having to do connections to other components differently than what has been practiced thousands of times, and with that, one has bought the somewhere-after-the-decimal-point “better” stone at the cost that less practiced processing results in later defects. In this respect, changing the stone often also involves changing the builder. What answer does your smart aleck have to that?
Be glad to have received the building permit, and don’t let yourself be distracted now by well-meaning interference.
 

RomanRot

2021-03-25 18:02:47
  • #6


Great, that's exactly how our energy consultant and structural engineer responded to me.

Thank you all.
 

Similar topics
09.09.2015Steinfrage => Summer Thermal Insulation12
18.09.2019Build the garage yourself - Calculate the statics?28
04.01.2023Retaining wall 2 m high without static report?10
28.08.2021summer thermal protection - reduction of windows?22

Oben