CJhome20
2021-08-28 14:44:49
- #1
Hello,
my question relates to the following situation.
Mr. X and Mrs. X have built a house in a good location and took out a loan for financing. They have two children together and are currently divorcing. Mrs. X continues to live in the house with both children. She alone is currently responsible for servicing the loan. The repayment (since a relatively high repayment rate was agreed upon at the time) has been almost suspended by the financing bank as a gesture of goodwill (and documented in writing). The term of this agreement lasts almost until the end of the fixed interest period. This is to enable Mrs. X to "stay living" there. Both have signed the loan agreement, which will be terminated at the end of the fixed interest period to avoid further indebting Mr. X. Mr. X is not registered in the land register.
Regarding the numbers:
- Fixed interest period ends in 2.5 years
- Outstanding balance then still about €340,000
- Current house and land value approximately €680,000
- Mr. X is entitled to €100,000 from the marriage (capital gains, the money is tied up in the house)
- Mrs. X’s total debts amount to about €440,000, the rest belongs to her (€240,000)
- Mrs. X earns under €2,000 from her job, she also receives about €1,400 in child benefits and child support. Both children will each reach the age of 18 during the further financing period in about 10 years.
- Mr. X’s income plays no role in a refinancing/follow-up financing.
Mr. X has three options in this situation (as unlikely as it may be for Mr. X to choose one or the other, they exist):
1. He re-enters a loan agreement, e.g., as a guarantor. Mrs. X would then have to take out a loan of €340,000.
2. Deferred payment or waives €100,000. Even in this case, Mrs. X would have to take out a loan of €340,000.
3. He insists on a €100,000 payout, which would force Mrs. X to take out financing of €440,000.
But to not go too deeply into the overall financial situation, the following question: to those of you who are currently more involved in banking and financing than I am:
Is it possible to find a bank that would grant Mrs. X a loan of at least €340,000 under the conditions mentioned above? And if yes, at what interest rate would that be possible?
Side note: The currently financing bank does not really see this possibility at the moment, but is reviewing the situation in detail once again. What might be feared is that a bank could be found which in a worst-case scenario says: Well, if Mrs. X stops paying, she can just sell the house and the bank will get its money back anyway (corresponding to a certain residual risk) because of the value.
Thanks in advance for your assessment.
my question relates to the following situation.
Mr. X and Mrs. X have built a house in a good location and took out a loan for financing. They have two children together and are currently divorcing. Mrs. X continues to live in the house with both children. She alone is currently responsible for servicing the loan. The repayment (since a relatively high repayment rate was agreed upon at the time) has been almost suspended by the financing bank as a gesture of goodwill (and documented in writing). The term of this agreement lasts almost until the end of the fixed interest period. This is to enable Mrs. X to "stay living" there. Both have signed the loan agreement, which will be terminated at the end of the fixed interest period to avoid further indebting Mr. X. Mr. X is not registered in the land register.
Regarding the numbers:
- Fixed interest period ends in 2.5 years
- Outstanding balance then still about €340,000
- Current house and land value approximately €680,000
- Mr. X is entitled to €100,000 from the marriage (capital gains, the money is tied up in the house)
- Mrs. X’s total debts amount to about €440,000, the rest belongs to her (€240,000)
- Mrs. X earns under €2,000 from her job, she also receives about €1,400 in child benefits and child support. Both children will each reach the age of 18 during the further financing period in about 10 years.
- Mr. X’s income plays no role in a refinancing/follow-up financing.
Mr. X has three options in this situation (as unlikely as it may be for Mr. X to choose one or the other, they exist):
1. He re-enters a loan agreement, e.g., as a guarantor. Mrs. X would then have to take out a loan of €340,000.
2. Deferred payment or waives €100,000. Even in this case, Mrs. X would have to take out a loan of €340,000.
3. He insists on a €100,000 payout, which would force Mrs. X to take out financing of €440,000.
But to not go too deeply into the overall financial situation, the following question: to those of you who are currently more involved in banking and financing than I am:
Is it possible to find a bank that would grant Mrs. X a loan of at least €340,000 under the conditions mentioned above? And if yes, at what interest rate would that be possible?
Side note: The currently financing bank does not really see this possibility at the moment, but is reviewing the situation in detail once again. What might be feared is that a bank could be found which in a worst-case scenario says: Well, if Mrs. X stops paying, she can just sell the house and the bank will get its money back anyway (corresponding to a certain residual risk) because of the value.
Thanks in advance for your assessment.