Different results of steam diffusion. Which one is correct?

  • Erstellt am 2009-06-27 18:07:32

Truk

2009-06-27 18:07:32
  • #1
If I calculate the exterior wall of a post-and-beam construction with WUFI resp. the program Energieeinsparverordnung Wärme-Dampf from Rowa-Soft, I get very different results. With WUFI, the total water content in the component decreases significantly (which is therefore okay), with the program from Rowa-Soft the vapor diffusion is not fulfilled. Which result is more likely? )Bau ist 33 Jahre alt und hat nirgends Dampfbremsen).
 

Danton

2009-06-27 19:33:00
  • #2
Hello Truk,

unfortunately, I am not familiar with the two programs you used for the calculations.

The programs for the Energy Saving Ordinance all seem to be not quite mature yet. But it is also an extremely complex area.

In the October 08 issue (Issue 10) of the Deutsches IngenieurBlatt, the test results of 6 programs for the Energy Saving Ordinance (all professional software) were presented. All programs were tested on the same building with the same inputs, yet 6 different results were obtained.
This means that none of the results necessarily has to be a correct result. Software for calculation according to the Energy Saving Ordinance is therefore currently not yet reliable.
This might not necessarily help you, but perhaps explains the different results.

Best regards from the Osnabrück region
 

Similar topics
29.04.2010Energy Saving Ordinance 2009 even without solar?16
07.06.2013Is it mandatory to build according to the Energy Saving Ordinance (2009)?12
23.10.2016Thermal insulation, Energy Saving Ordinance, KFW 70 / 55 / 40 - Your experiences31
19.06.2015Build according to KFW 70 or the Energy Saving Ordinance 201442
15.12.2019Aerated concrete exterior wall vs. Energy Saving Ordinance13
09.07.2015Energy Saving Ordinance Proof vs. Energy Saving Ordinance Proof + KfW-70 Proof13
19.10.2015New energy saving regulation from 2016 -> What to build?30
23.10.2015Energy Saving Ordinance 2014 - Gas boiler without solar?38
10.01.2017Energy Saving Ordinance 2016 / KFW55 / Gas + Solar in 201628
24.12.2015Single-family house, Energy Saving Ordinance 2016, developer recommends additional insulation - is it sensible?39
24.03.2016How can information such as the Energy Saving Ordinance 2016 be accessed?14
09.05.2016Compliance with the 2016 Energy Saving Ordinance with the following heating14
30.08.2016Construction and Performance Description - Contract including Energy Saving Ordinance 201415
11.02.2017KfW loan in 2017 for a house under the 2016 Energy Saving Ordinance17
23.02.2017New construction according to the 2016 Energy Saving Ordinance no longer possible without a ventilation/exhaust system?40
27.02.2017Difference between Energy Saving Ordinance 2014 and Energy Saving Ordinance 201612
14.04.2017House construction from concrete vs Energy Saving Ordinance 201631
19.07.2017How can one circumvent the Energy Saving Ordinance and avoid bureaucratic madness?162
16.07.2017Energy Saving Ordinance, KFW55, KFW40 or KFW40 Plus19

Oben