Contract clause on counterclaims

  • Erstellt am 2014-11-08 22:42:10

Vega82

2014-11-08 22:42:10
  • #1
Good evening,

I have a question regarding a contractual component of our work contract.
There is the clause:
"The client can only offset against undisputed or legally established counterclaims."

From this, I understand that in the case of defects, the legal route is generally the only option for me.
So it is not sufficient to have them determined and recorded by a building surveyor?

Is this a common clause?
How can it be better defined in our favor?
 

ypg

2014-11-08 23:42:22
  • #2
Honestly... I had to google that out of curiosity.
Now it gets exciting!

BGH, judgment of 07.04.2011, file no. VII ZR 209/07
§ 9 para. 1 AGBG (no longer in force); § 307 para. 1 Building Code

"The BGH ruled that the frequently used standard contract clause 'Set-off ... is only permitted with an undisputed or legally established claim' in architect contracts, where a contract for work and services is assumed, violates § 9 para. 1 AGBG (today: § 307 para. 1 Building Code) and is therefore invalid. It is unclear whether this decision only concerns the law of contracts for work and services, for which it was made. ..."

I think that is essentially the same.
They probably simply did not change the contract for work and services back then or do not themselves know about the judgment.

Regards Yvonne
 

Similar topics
05.03.2020House contract signed40
28.04.2014Cost estimate - contract for work16
19.02.2015Development costs §127 Building Code12
07.05.2015Have the work contract checked by a professional37
06.07.2015Termination of work contract for house construction (before construction)14
22.09.2015Building Code - Developer Contract - Postponement of Contractual Handover Date14
28.09.2016Question about early repayment and clause in the contract41
08.08.2018Withdrawal from the work contract within the withdrawal period23
02.11.2018Is the bad weather clause applicable as an excuse for the general contractor?10
15.10.2019Questions on the interpretation of § 34 Building Code59
14.04.2020Security deposit according to §650 of the Building Code20
27.01.2020How do I get out of a contract for work?11
06.05.2020Liberation § 31 Building Code: Roof pitch, roof shape, roof structures15
29.08.2020Net cold rent lease contract clause for real estate loan35
10.04.2021Delays with the general contractor, no deadline set according to § 650 Building Code65
21.08.2021§34 Building Code: Building Window and Garage21
29.12.2022Special right of termination according to § 489 Building Code - Refunds15
07.05.2022Work contract with exclusion §14/1522
14.08.2023Unclear clause in the development plan but authority does not answer questions23
23.10.2023Judgment on construction power supply - assessments / experiences?10

Oben